Search results

  1. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Sweet! My BBEG's are immortal now!

    Does it say what happens to the old body? That could be a great way to convince people the old wizard died if the old body stays around.
  2. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Sweet! My BBEG's are immortal now!

    Does the spell move your conscous into the new body? If it doesn't then your character is still dying and then you just have an NPC copy of him.
  3. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Nerf to Divine Sense

    The most annoying part of threads like this is no on actually ever says what the ability does.
  4. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Necromancer, now Goodman, is there a 5e OGL the general public doesn't know about?

    It works by getting the games to the consumer faster then a possible C&D happens so they can get the fast cash.
  5. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) First Legendary Monster!

    Let's start with the basics. What is a Legendary creature? Any definition on what that means? Is it kind of like a template or something for unique creatures?
  6. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Goodman Games Announces 5e Modules

    My concern is are they going to be any good? When 3e came out we had modules written quickly for it and while many of those had some cool story lines in them the mechanics where not well done. When 4e we had the same issue except I wasn't even impressed with the plots of the modules. Coming out...
  7. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Instant gratification versus saving money

    I have zero interest in running games and supporting stores that have bad customer service and worse habits. I understand the need for gaming stores to keep the hobby alive and I'm not for the end of all hobby stores just the few local ones I have. They do run games there and they do benefit the...
  8. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Summoning Spells

    Wow, that sounds like an evil option that should be in the DMG.
  9. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Instant gratification versus saving money

    I'm waiting for the local gaming stores to go out of business. I'm getting it from Amazon. I would not being using in the next couple of weeks and I can turn the money saved into more gaming books.
  10. Crothian

    20th Anniversary Mage and others?

    The Mage book isn't out yet but the Vampire and Werewolf books have been great.
  11. Crothian

    The Theory of Everything (trailer)

    Of course it is. Is this not what the 60's taught us?
  12. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Review of New Players Handbook Posted at Acts of Geek...

    I don't think the purpose of the review it to review 5e but to be first and get as much traffic on their site.
  13. Crothian

    Merchant class (GAZ11)

    The class only works if you are going to do merchant type things. They might have done it this way so it can work in basic D&D, and first and second edition AD&D. The cover does specify that it is compatible with all that.
  14. Crothian

    Merchant class (GAZ11)

    I can't say I ever knew that was in there. I had to go get my copy of it but luckily I have a physical copy of the Gazetteers. It's odd. It doesn't seem to be a class of its own. I would call it more like a Template that gains levels then an additional class. The merchant does not gain...
  15. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Two-Weapon Fighting Style seems ... bad

    I think people posting numbers and analysis of DPR as if it is the only factor that matter really miss the point of what an RPG is. I have never seen a campaign that rolling the highest damage matters.
  16. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Feats / Multiclassing

    That's great. GM: "While exploring the tower a demon appears!" Player 1: "No, I don't like that. What do you guess think." Player 2: "Ya, interesting suggestion for what is in the tower but we are low and HP and spells and that sounds tough." Player 3: "I concur, but I do think we find...
  17. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Two-Weapon Fighting Style seems ... bad

    I think what people are missing is that fighting with two weapons is awesome looking. :D
  18. Crothian

    D&D 5E (2014) Feats / Multiclassing

    Multi classing yes unless is turns out to be something different then we are thinking. I find the secret to make sure people don't multi class to abuse the rules is to not play with those people. Feats are a no at this time.
  19. Crothian

    Pathfinder 1E Advanced Race Guide and amount of Racial point spent

    I'd stick with what fits. The system is a bit inexact so just create how you feel it should be and then see how it works out in play.
  20. Crothian

    Pathfinder 1E Is there a magic item that would negate or lower the penalties for using over-sized weapons?

    I'd make it a minor artifact so that it would be unique and no chance of others getting one. I'd let her research it and go on a quest for it. Having something like this earned I think makes it more important in the game and feel like reward. Maybe she would have to journey to the giants land...
Top