Search results

I like the idea of partner spells, I have been thinking about something in that vein since the 2014 MM introduced Hag covens. I also think you could have partnered martial maneuverers too. Not sure if you did that in your forthcoming martial book.

If by "rampantly overused" you mean "used just as much as modifiers were in other editions" then I'd agree. While I don't disagree with you, I do think the game would be better served if Adv. was much more rare.

Yes, that is what I was trying to emulate with my proposed revision to Magic Resistance in 5e.

Yep, Archfiends typically had a good deal of MR in 1e. Demogorgon had 95%.

I might suggest Forge for Melkor too. Or whatever corresponds to making terrific monsters!

A version of this one: post #83 With a version of this explanation: post #11 I am busy this weekend, but plan to get this updated with version 4 next week.

Here is the thread you are referring to: Magic Resistance: What was Old is New And to answer your question I have not playtested any of the methods yet. I actually haven't even revised the OP with my preferred method derived from the discussion in the thread!

Never played with a warlock PC.

I don't think it was an issue of fairness, but what is fun. No one, PC or DM, likes to do nothing for a turn. That being said, this has never really been an issue for my group (for the PCs or DM).

Interesting, we haven't noticed that.

Both the 2014 & 2024 version force movement

That was my thought as well.

I was really wondering why multiple modrons of the same tier can't "help" each other.

OK, that is not how I was understanding "swingy," but that makes sense. Follow up question: how do things like Bless or other modifiers work in the aura?

I don't follow. If there is no die-roll, how can it be more swingy or swingy at all. It is the same on every roll. That seems like the opposite of swingy or am I missing something?

I love the idea. My only question at this time is: why limit the group mind bonus to the higher CR modron? Is there a downside to giving any modron the benefit?

I am always sad to see someone leave as well (and sometimes try to convince them to stay). I do not know who you are talking about, but I hope they find there way back. Once we realize we don't have to engage, I think the discussion becomes a lot easier.

It is frustrating. I know it was a problem I have had before and worked to change. Now I generally try to take the attitude that, in most cases, people are only talking about their opinion even if they do not state that.

I am just about finished with updating to the 2024 CR values and I have made a few other changes too. I am just having a hard time with the revised full Primoridal dragon version of Tiamat. Once I get that nut cracked I will post the updated PDF. PS - Welcome to EnWorld!

Maybe, but @Micah Sweet did say: "...makes no sense to me..." They are clearly framing it from their perspective not a universal statement. And what is or is not verisimilitudinous is subjective of course. I don't think we need to defend our personal perspectives on this subject.