Search results

This adventure will have big shoes to fill if it is meant to replace The Lost Mines of Phandelver. I am pleased to see that they are shrinking the scope of the adventure, 6 levels is a lot for a starter set, and 3 seem much more reasonable.

Yes, grognards always have the originals and 40 years of fan-developed content. Your lawn holds no interest here. It does not reach new audiences and that is the shame of it. Nostalgia is a powerful draw, but it is not enough to breathe new life into Oerth. They should play up that both good...

I had quite a few brilliant players who were LD and unsupported academically if not for BOCES technical classes. Special Education was a lot of throw them in a classroom at the end of the hall out of sight in the 80s in American education or label them behaviors and send them to vocational school.

I would love to see Greyhawk for 5E. I love Greyhawk. The WoG boxset was my first purchase with birthday money as a kid. I played a lot to Living Greyhawk in 3E (Kingdom of Keoland represent), so it is near and dear to my heart. That being said, I would like to see Greyhawk updated a bit. I have...

The Tradesman always seemed the odd man out in Spelljammer ship names. All the rest of the human ships have animal names, i.e. squid hammerhead, octopus, dragonfly. The tradesman is a fish shape, I don't know that it particularly looks like a flying fish, but it should have a more elaborate name...

There is a setup for them using critical hits in their D&D campaign. In S3, when Will is in Castle Byers there is a copy of the Best of Dragon V which had an article of critical hits and fumbles tables. I enjoyed the scene. I thought there were a few inaccuracies and anachronisms, but it got...

The rolling of d10s was for Lady Applejack a 14th level thief and her thief abilities, maybe assassin abilities. I thought the scene of the game was pretty highlight accurate even if a battlemat seems anachronistic. We used miniatures (badly painted) and measured with a tape measure on the...

I applaud the concept but the execution is flawed. The mechanics are super flavorful but punish the player for using his class. The strain concept is strong but the tracks seem arbitrary and crippling to a traditional adventuring party. Strain almost necessitates a 5-minute workday followed by a...

I am not so excited about these minis but excited for the rules that would support the need for these minis. I hope we get a ship-scale combat similar to Wildjammer.

Neogi are not really similar at all. When they get old, the other neogi begin biting the elderly and injecting enough venom to turn the elder into a mindless bloated host to the next generation of neogi. Other races are only food or slaves. They are a race that makes the illithid look neutral...

Neogi are every evil condensed in a small spider/moray eel body with Umber Hulk bodyguards. Not much like alien or predator. There are Spelljammer analogs of both though. Spelljammer took a lot from the 70s and 80s manga. Guyver, Mecha, Kaiju all prominently strut around along with Klingon orcs...

The Whispered One, Lord of the Spider Throne, keeper of secrets. I love me some Vecna and seeing him in a product this year would be fantastic. No mention of Die, Vecna, Die...

I hope they include the Bionoids and Spirit Warriors. Really the Unhuman wars were a great setting. Giant undead insect mechas and the elven warriors turned into battle monsters that are cast out when the battle is over. I also hope they don't continue the Arcane are behind everything! Very boring.

I was mainly critiquing the use of the 'Disneyfying' angle. Duergar can be a lot of different things. It does sound out of context with the duergar monster entries. How much lore is included in MP:MotM? (not just duergar but overall)

They Did they name a dwarf Grumpy? Gave them a duergar ennui song?

The story of Yellow Submarine is not too weird, mainly the visuals, and that it is a musical comedy. Change Blue Meanies to Neogi and put Pepperland on an asteroid or small planet. Treasure Planet is good, but Pirates of Dark Water is better! Jack Kirby Apokolypse or Eternals runs work well...

I agree with DEFCON1. They want a Spelljammer game, they want a Jack Kirby pirate fantasy adventure. Too weird might mean 'too mechanically weird' or too many house rules. All this can be hashed out in Session 0. You are already reaching out to try and get more definitive answers from the...

Nope. Put me in the Nazis do not get to be in society unless they fully recant their antisocial ethos. Sometimes you can deplatform. Sometimes you punch them in the head. White Supremacy is a cancer that must be combated at its very whisper. NuTSR can enjoy another bag of sodium crusted members...

This is a non-issue. It is not new, nor is it a cash grab. "I don't like how other industries have handled a different system" is not an actual concern.

Dark Sun confirmed! (RIP Spelljammer confirmed) Although these images are renders and not actual products. The mix looks good. I admit I am more excited for what 3D sculptors will do for the STL market in regards to ship miniatures for space battles.