Search results

  1. C

    Melee Weapon Mastery twice?

    I don't have a rules citation handy, but I can't believe the bonuses would stack. They'd only overlap.
  2. C

    Low Point Buy = negative LA?

    Suppose that, as a DM, I were to offer a negative LA in exchange for a low point buy. I.e. instead of generating a 3rd level character with a 32 point buy, a player could make a 4th level character with a lower point buy. Or even a 5th level character with a still lower point buy. What...
  3. C

    What is the standard ability score set? Are most games playing too high?

    There are also various powers tied to an ability bonus. The amount of healing a paladin does; the number of extra AoOs you can take with Combat reflexes. The number of turnings per day a cleric has (which strongly affects how good the cleric's turning feats are). Stuff like that. I think it...
  4. C

    Medusa & Mind Flayer "couple" - where is it?

    Nope. I just went through it- no Medusas at all, let alone an illithid/medusa pairing.
  5. C

    Balance For Irresistable Damage?

    I agree. I think that 5d6 for a 5th level spell would be all right (average 17.5). 15d2 for a 4th level spell (average 22.5) might be OK, but I'd hesitate to allow it to set that precedent.
  6. C

    No spell resistance vs. Orb spells? Why?

    True, but it seems that the designers of the orbs disagreed with this perspective. The option they provided (single target direct damage that replaces an SR check with a ranged touch attack) is unsatisfactory to some people; I just want to point out that there are potential fixes besides making...
  7. C

    No spell resistance vs. Orb spells? Why?

    It would be nice if arcanists could make some kind of direct magical attack against golems. Sure the orbs might be too good as written, but I can't help but feel that making them SR (yes) nerfs them too much. How about a compromise? Say that yes, the energy collected by the orb spells is...
  8. C

    New categories of favored enemy

    Ok. Basically I have a problem with the classification of Ranger favored enemies. How is it possible that griffons and hydras have more in common than humans and elves? Here's the basic data about the Ranger's favored enemy. It includes the material from the SRD, a paraphrased version of the...
  9. C

    No Man's Land (Recruitment Closed... Sort of)

    It seems clear that an abjurant champion is supposed to be able to benefit twice; once from an abjuration spell that gives an armor bonus, and again from an abjuration spell that gives a shield bonus. But I don't know of any abjuration spell that gives an armor bonus. If I were DM I'd allow...
  10. C

    D&D 3.x [3.5] Extra Favored Enemy

    Doesn't the text of it give you a favored enemy at +1? The favored enemy mechanic was revised from 3.0 => 3.5, so the feat should be adapted too. There is the Living Greyhawk conversion document, but it seems to have been overlooked by the WotC page, so I'm not sure it counts. It just seems...
  11. C

    No Man's Land (Recruitment Closed... Sort of)

    Regarding Whin Z. Roe... Does Abjurant Champion's Abjurant Armor class ability enhance greater mage armor? AFAIK it's a conjuration (creation) spell, not an abjuration, and should only give a +6 AC. Mind you, the folks who gave the sample NPC in CM 153 apparently thought the ability should...
  12. C

    D&D 3.x [3.5] Extra Favored Enemy

    According to this page the feat had not been revised as of 01/13/2005. But the absence of information to the contrary makes me think that no, it hasn't been published in a 3.5 book.
  13. C

    D&D 3.x [3.5] Extra Favored Enemy

    Thread Necromancy This is a 2003 thread! Has a 3.5 version of this feat been published yet? Or is the 3.0 one still the default?
  14. C

    Favored enemy: Arcanist?

    Thanks Klaus!
  15. C

    [Math] WotC Challenge Ratings

    Note that the previous post has been edited. The discussion in the OotS 439 thread made me realize that the xp mechanic in the first post is not what is given by the DMG. I was treating a multi-creature encounter as if it were a creature whose CR was the EL of the whole encounter. And it...
  16. C

    Favored enemy: Arcanist?

    I could have sworn I read about an alternative class feature for the Ranger that allowed him to take arcanists (including warlocks) as a favored enemy. But now I can't find it. Anyone know where something like this can be found? Or am I just dreaming it?
  17. C

    The Meaning of Skill Ranks

    It's very odd, but I remember this thread as having a link to this article which talks about skill DCs and their meaning in relation to character level. One of the startling things about the article is its claim that folks like Albert Einstein and Aragorn are only 5th level characters. So...
  18. C

    Prismatic ray?

    It's a fifth level spell, so you'd think it would work like prismatic spray, but for only one target. The question was asked over at the wizards boards: Prismatic Ray clarification please? There's another link that is not coming through for me, but google has a cached version: here...
  19. C

    Inspire Courage Optimization

    I think this was mentioned before, but mind blank prevents morale bonuses from working, right? It's a pity that a character optimized for inspire courage will find their ability useless at high and epic levels, when the other party members get this particular protection. Is it quite definite...
  20. C

    Classes not dependent on high abilities

    Could a moderator please close this thread? People seem intent on thread-crapping it, so I think I'll wait until another time to revisit the issue.
Top