Search results

Now there are two. Let it be heard that any man that knows not of Diablo game play; Them I shall call my brother.

Apples and oranges. Magpie goes out of their way to have a presence at gencon; they are the contact for all 130 events that the Avatar RPG has there. It is not organic. Again; I am not saying that the Avatar RPG is not profitable for them. It clearly is. People like their favorite IP's. What...

Nothing is a D&D level of success. It's all niche. But there are degrees of niche. And when most in this thread are discussing a game being "widely played" it is in reference to games that have established a sizeable and notable network effect of their own within the hobby like; WFRP, PF2...

Because the majority of the backers are not RPG people. They are Sanderson fans. And it is just collectable merch to the overwhelming majority of them. They buy because Sanderson did a thing for them to buy. Sanderson is smart. Correct. Collectors and merch buyers that do not play the...

GS is not as crunchy. Now don't get me wrong, GS is still very much a medium crunch game in the realm of 5e. But SW is a step above it, and does several things differently. I have the fan translation of SW2.5, so there is no need for me to get the hard copy as GS is the game I'd present to my...

And this is not a good thing... Many a company has ruined a good thing by trying to squeeze every ounce of 'profit' from their customers that they can. Oversaturation is a thing. Killing the goose that lays the golden eggs is a thing. Just because MTG continues to do well in terms of...

MAPS is what they should have thrown all this effort behind. More and more SIGIL just looks like a video game with extra steps...

Take a look at Old Swords Reign, and Into the Unknown. Both are attempts to distill 5e to OSR levels. Personally I like the way Old Swords Reign does characters, and the procedural stuff from Into the Unknown. ACKSII does fighters rather well, probably the best of the three.

They will never get the crossover audience $pending they want. Mtg and D&D are two very different games with two different player bases. Most mtg players could care less about any mtg lore. They care if they have a winning deck. You do get some crossover, but it is largely the rpg people...

ACKSII AC system is the easiest thing in the world to fix: Subtract 10 from the classes attack throw to get a conventional Attack bonus. Add 10 to AC to get conventional ascending armor class. But I agree that it shouldn't require this fix; it's different for no reason...

I don’t think you need go to far afield; take a look at pundits Baptism of Fire. Same system as L&D. He goes into pagan magic that should be relatively easy to re-flavor: astrology, talismans, banishing, cures, curses, folk magic, glamour, rune magic, and spirit magic. I’d advise getting the...

Yes. I've always thought that if you cap HP progression around lvl 6 or so. And the 6-9 th level spells are largely yeeted along with the "skip button" spells; you can design a whole game of 20 levels around the 'sweet spot'. All under the auspices of RPGs "dying"... In my opinion; RPGs go...

At 6:59 Prof DM: "Is it true that the mandate for 4th edition was; make this like World of Warcraft." Mearls: "Yes."

Who's getting excited? WotC says they will do the following: Setting books Setting Products Sounds like multiple books for different settings to me. I do not see that as a stretch. No one has made any such claims. Just pointing out what seems to be a very clear change in direction from...

Boo. They should have stuck to their guns. In backing down on the Drow, they now lack any compelling reason not to.

Yet for two decades WotC went around telling everyone; multiple settings = product line no,no. But now: "It'll be ok because we're doing it..." That being said; I absolutely agree that it remains to be seen is if the choice to support more settings pays off.

Of course it's not the same situation. 5e is in a very different place financially. They are not going under anytime soon... But they are signaling that they will do a number of settings with support: Setting books Setting Products Multiverse Different worlds A much different proposition that...

So maybe my memory is a little hazy, but wasn't releasing a bunch of different settings that divided the fanbase one of the things WotC circa 2000 pointed to that contributed to TSR's bankruptcy?

"Reroll" that's actually a clever little term... You don't even need to have the PCs be the characters from the films - you can just run them as regular adventures in a current campaign if the genre's are compatible. In my current Vaesen campaign I turned the 1999 Sleepy Hollow film into a...

Agreed, when you put it all on a table, roll low or roll high doesn't matter. On first blush maybe. But from a design point of view Roll high does have advantages. i.e. For contested rolls, you do not need to insert resistance tables, or counter intuitive blackjack mechanics. High-roll =...