Search results

Ok, did some musing about how I'd want to handle some more mechanical stuff. My goal here continues to be to hit the abstracted feel of dungeon crawling without getting bogged down in mechanics too much. So trying to use the core DH rules and mechanics as much as I can. First up, the crawling...

Went back a few pages, wanted to note again that "skilled play" and "player skill" are, in this context, very different. I think in an earlier set of comments I misused these to some degree. When I see "player skill" emphasized as per the OP/title, it's generally talking about "using your...

Well, we talked a little bit at one point about using flashbacks from blades to the dark and then they went ahead and built that into an environment, didn’t they?

Yup, and the book tells players this! “Before creating Experiences, you’ll want to have a solid idea of who your character is; the background questions are especially helpful for this. When you’re ready, work with your GM to create two Experiences that have shaped your character.” If it’s not...

Do you not have the book? Example Phrases in there are things like: “Phrases: Catch Me If You Can, Fake It Till You Make It, First Time’s the Charm, Hold the Line, I Won’t Let You Down, I’ll Catch You, I’ve Got Your Back, Knowledge Is Power, Nature’s Friend, Never Again, No One Left Behind...

"Yet you only want one thing: to see your players triumph. So you craft malevolent villains worth defeating. You sculpt marvelous treasures worth stealing. You fill the world with rot, darkness, and death so it can be driven back by sword, spell, and flame. Through this, you offer an...

Oh, you can't drop Connections or Bonds. Integrating a short "how do you all know each other already" with some fun evocative questions is a delightful part of group formation. It's a Must for me in any game these days (I'd be tempted to steal some of His Majesty the Worm's Bonds tbh). I guess...

and "Ask questions and build on the answers."

Sure, ok. Lets take a step back and look at the core DH character assumptions then and what we might want to change: Class / subclass. "Role-based archetypes" that also gate your abilities. Heritage. Ancestry + community (or nature/nurture). Per the Homebrew kit, when they were thinking about...

Well i loathe when you have a bunch of distinct species that are just masks over humanity. Core DH’s ancestries are really species and IMO could use some additional distinction. When I wrote my fantasy tropes campaign frame one thing I did was assert some additional differences about each...

Yeah, I'm a little less into early S&S and a little more into "classic dungeon crawling." I think I like the split of "nature" vs "nurture" you get with ancestry/community (background). Some walk thoughts: - Collapse communities down a bit, and provide d6 options of backgrounds on each...

Interesting. Are you thinking of generic Domain cards? Like there’s a “Dungeoneering” domain anybody can pick from? Or like at L2 a fighter can choose “Squire” or something

When a PC succeeds with Hope, I tend to ask if they want to follow-up or pass the spotlight. Once in a while they follow the fiction and take a second action, but most of the time they've handed it over to somebody else.

Ok, because I was one of the people in the DH thread saying "this isn't a great game for classic-style dungeon crawling" over and over, I'm now pretty invested into seeing what we can do with it. Having read the Shadowdark Quickstart core yesterday I'm really impressed with teh simplicity and...

Well, I might play around with taking the core of Shadowdark and making it into a campaign frame to hit the vibe of dungeon crawling. I was reading through the quick start this morning and the emphasis on "pushing back the dark" is actually an excellent thematic match for DH's mechanics and...

I think it would be far more interesting to start with a DH base and see what you need to par away or tweak to get a dungeon crawler. Shadowdark is built off d20 after all, and cares about a lot of stuff that DH abstracts away. Keeping that level of abstraction but hitting the vibe of dungeon...

If you wanted to play with real-time light you could make it a Countdown (6), ticks down on 10 min increments.

Really nice set of GM tracker sheets somebody tossed up on the subreddit.

Inspired by the shadow dark melding thread & thoughts about an ancient ruin my players might be exploring I thought I'd do a little brainstorming on a generic environment you could layer over any dungeon-y style place: THE SHADOWED DARK Exploration, all tiers A place of velvet deep shadows that...

Have torches run on a countdown that gutters on rolls with Fear. “Attack the light” is an easy add to DH Moves (there’s a couple it can fall under - Change the Environment & Take Something), and adversary actions. You'd probably have to do a pretty comprehensive reconsideration of what classes...