Search results

  1. cmbarona

    Begging to be errata'd: Archer Ranger At-Wills

    You get ability damage as the power specifies, which Ranged Basic Attack does, so yes. Just to point it out so there's no confusion, and since we're talking about Rangers, they don't add ability damage on Twin Strike.
  2. cmbarona

    The Videogame comparison

    Hmm... come to think of it, making a WC3 custom map based on D&D 4e could be very fun... :)
  3. cmbarona

    Warlord: Knight's Move vs. Aid the Injured

    Here's my dilemma: I'm the only leader in our merry little band, and I'm an Inspiring Warlord. We recently got a new player, taking us up to 4 PCs, including myself, and we have no defender. Well, healing in battles is starting to get spread a little thin. I get the feeling my experience comes...
  4. cmbarona

    Trouble with Short Rest and Healing Word

    Son of a gnoll! Well, I suddenly feel short-changed as a Warlord. Oh, well. I can still stand on my own two feet as my party's healer. A pity there isn't even a feat for that feature for Warlords, though.
  5. cmbarona

    Trouble with Short Rest and Healing Word

    I'm a little confused about this statement. Healing Word and Inspiring Word are exactly the same, mechanically speaking. Did I miss something?
  6. cmbarona

    Racial Power: Dwarven Breath

    Depends on what the other half is...
  7. cmbarona

    Racial Power: Dwarven Breath

    I think it should be Constitution-based, working off the assumption that any dwarf at any given time will have a baseline of alcohol in his system based on how much ale he can drink before becoming ineffective in combat. I'd make it follow the Dragon Breath attack values (+2 at first level...
  8. cmbarona

    N00b question about basic attack

    Sounds like an interesting plot hook for a campaign: some evil magic company is strip-mining a country into ecological death. Time for rangers to step in (since there aren't any druids yet).
  9. cmbarona

    Warlord. A bad or a good Cleric?

    Technically, Commander's Strike doesn't work unless the warlord is within melee range of the target, but even if you knew this, I applaud you for making the decision to allow it to work for the sake of a badass encounter.
  10. cmbarona

    Warlord. A bad or a good Cleric?

    When and where Warlords use their powers will determine their effectiveness. I want to make this very clear: Warlords are near useless in a vacuum. Furious Smash is not there to deal damage, it's there to make sure your allies' Encounter and Daily powers hit mire often. Commander's Strike is far...
  11. cmbarona

    Warlord. A bad or a good Cleric?

    I play an Inspiring Warlord myself, and so far I've only had an ally go down once on my watch. It's worth mentioning that it was also the case that 1) the group was separated, and 2) we had a new player, so healing was spread a little thin. Since we have more people, I'm thinking of retraining...
  12. cmbarona

    Granted basic attacks, rolled by the granter rather than the grantee

    It honestly sounds like your friend just doesn't want to play a Warlord. I play an Inspiring Warlord myself, and I fully understand that it is not my job to acheive victory in combat, but to enable it. That's just what Warlords do. They are D&D 4E's quintessential team player, even more so than...
  13. cmbarona

    Teleport foes over a cliff - Forked Thread: Push+Wall=save

    Please correct me if I'm wrong, but I think your argument is incorrect. Paladins are mentioned in the flavor text of the Holy Avenger stat block. And even then, it just says that Paladins seek them, not that others don't. By contrast, Avaunt Foe's examined text is in the rules section of the...
  14. cmbarona

    Minotaur + Executioner's Axe = OMG!

    I've been wondering about this too, and I agree that WOTC missed this point. However, i imagine that they had their reasons for not making the Brutal property so universally applicable, perhaps because they take advantage of this mechanic elsewhere in some way (or will later), such as an item...
  15. cmbarona

    Questions about Commander's Strike + Sneak Attack

    It's option 1, use the Rogue's weapon enhancements. The Weapon keyword is just intended as a reminder that the Warlord must be in melee range in order for the strike to work. This allows for a Warlord using a Reach weapon to make a Commander's Strike from 2 squares away. Remember, weapons add...
  16. cmbarona

    Halflings?

    I have to respectfully disagree. A couple of night ago, my Dragonborn Warlord with Enlarged Dragon Breath took out five minions (out of the eight there were) in a single minor action at the beginning of a battle. With only three people on our team, and no defender, this made for an awesome move...
  17. cmbarona

    D&D 4E 4e: the metagame.

    Disengage, All I can say in response is that I hope your players are having fun. If your DMing methods work for them, fine. But I can't imagine wanting to play at your table, myself. It sounds like I'd be coming to your game to be disciplined, not to have fun.
  18. cmbarona

    Advantage of not doing physical damage?

    1 & 2) Yes, although keep in mind the "weapon" keyword is required in order to add the weapon's energy to a power. And this really is a key to answering these first two questions: these keywords are added, not changed. Untyped damage is more of a blank slate, so the damage type isn't converted...
  19. cmbarona

    Advantage of not doing physical damage?

    Ah! I found it! PHB 226: "When you use a magic item as part of a racial power or a class power, the keywords of the item's power and the other power all apply. For instance, if a paladin uses a flaming sword to attack with a power that deals radiant damage, the power deals both fire damage and...
  20. cmbarona

    Advantage of not doing physical damage?

    Ginnel, You can choose to shift between physical and lightning damage on all attacks as a free action. The crit is always Xd6 lightning, but you can otherwise turn the lightning off for lightning resistant creatures. To the OP, I don't have the PHB with me, so I can't quote this, but I...
Top