Search results

Yes, there is a misunderstanding. The items, spells, monsters, NPCs present in the book aren't the iconic ones associated with MtG. What is present in this book is uninteresting and not what MtG fans want to see in D&D. There are far more monsters, items, spells and NPCs from MtG's lore that...

Without the MtG elements, it is just a vanilla setting not much different from the FR. It is a bit pointless.

Guilds, factions, clans, groups, whatever, rarely work for PCs. They often do not mess well when members of different groups are together. Like member of the Boros Legion working with a member of the the Cult of Radkos? At least Sigil is an interesting location and connects all the planes. Who...

Magic the Gathering lore? Yeah. You'll be disappointed. There is a rich history on Dominaria and many other planes that compose the MtG universe. There are many story arcs often linked to cards blocks. Just trying to explain how the Phyrixians tried to invade Dominaria and the aftermath would...

I do. It gives me tools to make campaigns and aventures. It is also fun to read. Since 4e WotC has forgotten that lore is also one of the reasons people bought D&D products.

That is like saying a Forgottem Realms book isn't a D&D book.

A concept that comes from 4e's PHB excluding the gnome race and some classes. The effect is even bigger with this campaign book as Ravnica isn't in he Ravnica campaign guide. But also MtG elements aren't in the book either. And that is weird cause Ravnica is part of the MtG universe.

Ravnica isn't even in this book.

I know what is bothering me so much with this campaign string book. It suffers from the gnome effect. What is missing isn't gnomes though. It's the campaign setting. And planewalking. And iconic MtG spells, artifacts and monsters. And colored magic. Guilds aren't what MtG is about. This is a...

Yeah, this is just a book with factions in it. But they have no history in any DnD setting and the setting from which their come from isn't detailed. A Sigil supplement with its Factions would have made more sense. I was excited when I first heard this book was coming out. It was a new(ish)...

There are far more iconic spells, items and monsters in MtG than Black Lotus. Without them, the setting is as meaningful as Birthright.

There are far more iconic spells, items and monsters in MtG than Black Lotus. Without them, the setting is as meaningful as Birthright.

Are there any iconic MtG spells like Fork or iconic magic items/artifacts like a Black Lotus? That was what made merging DnD and MtG so attractive. Not guilds, the Ravnica setting or even new races.

Are there any iconic MtG spells like Fork or iconic magic items/artifacts like a Black Lotus? That was what made merging DnD and MtG so attractive. Not guilds, the Ravnica setting or even new races.

Isn't Kunena on another plane than Ravnica? There are no merfolk on Ravnica. Those are from the Ixalan (mesoamerica inspired) block.

The Golgari and the Conclave were done in prévois articles.

Aquameh.

The Roman general bad the upper ground.

It is the first time since 5e started that WotC is doing something new(-ish) with DnD. We should welcome originality as this edition has none.

I liked All Systems Red. It was fun, mainly because it was short. It didn't reinvent much though. The snarky narrative makes it the child of John Scalzi's snarky dialogues. I will not read more Murderbot stories, unless they are free like this one.