Search results

  1. thedungeondelver

    The worst of all editions? (humor)

    One time, this guy handed me a picture of him, he said,"Here's a picture of me when I was younger." Every picture is of you when you were younger. "Here's a picture of me when I'm older." "You son-of-a-bitch! How'd you pull that off? Lemme see that camera... what's it look like? "
  2. thedungeondelver

    The worst of all editions? (humor)

    I like how a comedy thread has become a slag older editions of D&D thread. In less than two pages.
  3. thedungeondelver

    The worst of all editions? (humor)

    The game's entire magic system is replaced by 1e AD&D psionics. Mandatory. You have to roll d% to try to not have them. Borrowing a page from HERO SYSTEM, there are now a simple-to-remember 22 character stats. Demihuman level limits are in play for humans, too. Except for Halflings*...
  4. thedungeondelver

    The worst of all editions? (humor)

    You mean EXALTED? :D
  5. thedungeondelver

    After DDXP, how are you feeling about D&En?

    As am I, in the same context.
  6. thedungeondelver

    D&D 5E (2014) My D&D Next Experience at DDXP

    The "cleric-is-only-a-battlefield-medic" is a sacred cow argument that needs to die (there, see? I can do that too.) Clerics are moderately skilled fighters They can banish undead, if not destroy them outright, or alternately force them to fight for the group They can employ spells to...
  7. thedungeondelver

    D&D 5E (2014) My D&D Next Experience at DDXP

    What do you want a thief to do if not sneak around and be all backstabby, lockpicky and so forth? If you're not doing those things you're not playing that class, you're playing a fighter who insists on wearing leather armor and soft boots! :D
  8. thedungeondelver

    D&D 5E (2014) The Classes and Races of my 5E Game - What will be yours?

    Whatever fits into WORLD OF GREYHAWK, specifically: Races: Humans Halflings Elves (gray/sylvan/wood/wild/valley - Drow are NPC monsters only thx.) Dwarves Gnomes Half-Orcs Half-Elves Half-Ogres Classes: Fighter/Ranger/Paladin/Cavalier(?) Cleric/Druid Thief/Assassin Magic-User/Illusionist...
  9. thedungeondelver

    D&D 5E (2014) A sidebar I'd like to see in the 5E PHB

    Sidebar hell, it needs to be reiterated in every major rule component discussion. Generating a character? Here's how you make a AD&D character. A 2e character. A 3.5 character. Use these options. Creating an encounter for the party? etc.
  10. thedungeondelver

    Reclaim the name of Paladin!

    How to "fix" the Paladin (By Billy, Age 42): "Monte, Mike...here's a copy of THREE HEARTS AND THREE LIONSby POUL ANDERSON. Now you just step in here, here's a spiral notebook and a few pens for each of you...that's right, pick a chair, get comfortable. No no, I'll take your laptops and cell...
  11. thedungeondelver

    "In the Style of" Older Editions

    Let me just say this about that... One thing I found the more I delved (ha!) into the online D&D community is/was that there are a lot of people with a hateboner for AD&D because they had really crappy powermonger DMs who thought the game was a wargame between them and the players, and a good...
  12. thedungeondelver

    What's your favorite edition of D&D (so far)?

    Because AD&D and 2e are separate products; note there is no break-out of PLAYERS OPTIONS for 2e or UNEARTHED ARCANA and all things afterward for AD&D. COMPANIONS, MASTER RULES & IMMORTALS fundamentally changed how Basic DUNGEONS & DRAGONS gets played. at least that's how I view it.
  13. thedungeondelver

    What's your favorite edition of D&D (so far)?

    ADVANCED DUNGEONS & DRAGONS ...but then you already knew I'd say that.
  14. thedungeondelver

    D&D 4E 5E as a Rewritten 4E with Flavor Bits from Other Editions?

    All I know is the mantra that's kept me optimistic through this has been: "include" what they will. Just leave the option(s) to switch things off for those who want them off and on for those who want them on, and they'll have a sweet game. If I crack the rulebook and there's no "switch" for...
  15. thedungeondelver

    D&D 4E 5E as a Rewritten 4E with Flavor Bits from Other Editions?

    It shouldn't be, but I'm starting to get the impression that's what it will be.
  16. thedungeondelver

    DDXP Begins Today!

    First of all, let me just say this about that: B2 KEEP ON THE BORDERLANDS? Cool. Very, very cool. While those sheets are impossible to read, I also don't see a lot of clutter on them so it could be that the base game is yes indeed a very streamlined and easy-to-snap-onto form factor. Looking...
  17. thedungeondelver

    D&D 5E (2014) 5e Greyhawk: What could it look like?

    An '81 WORLD OF GREYHAWK folio with an insert that reads "It's all OK. It was just a nightmare. There's no such thing as Sean K. Reynolds, Carl Sargent or Erik Mona." I kid! I kid! I think one that picks and chooses from the best-received post-Gygax material, adds a timeline and emphasizes...
  18. thedungeondelver

    There are going to be a lot of people disappointed.

    I think the new edition will be a great disappointment to people who expect it to be a Perfect Game that can replace whatever previous version of D&D they play. It won't be. AD&D isn't perfect. Original D&D isn't perfect. 2e isn't, nor was 3e, nor was 4e. However a game that features...
Top