Search results

I've already answered this multiple times. If a GM decides to slam a portcullis down, thus splitting the party in two, they're separating them. It doesn't matter if the actual game is AD&D or DungeonWorld, except that Bend Bars, Lift Gates is a part of Strength in one game and a fighter move...

Doing so actually requires you to understand the material (or else produce junk). And to understand the material, you need to think about it. So do you need to write an essay? No. But that means trad gamers who are actually designing and producing trad game material have put in as much thought...

Here's quite a big list of adventures for DW. I have an entire book of adventures for Monster of the Week called the Tome of Mysteries. There's a book of adventures, Nephews in Peril, for Brindlewood Bay, that's been sitting in my Drivethru wishlist for a while, and that's an even less...

The point is, you added something dangerous to the world. You did so in order to hinder the PCs' movements and weren't sure they could get past it ("I had no idea if or how they would be able to get to the other side of this. They did admirably.") That's thinking dangerously. The name of the...

Yeah, all those casual gamers certainly haven't created tens of thousands of pages of homebrew, personal settings, house rules, entire supplements, and philosophies over the decades. Because casual gamers are far too casual to think about their games in any sort of codified manner.

I think at this point you know what I mean. You're being unnecessarily pedantic here in order to claim that you don't do a particular thing that you do. Like, when you say that you decided to ask the players what to do after the attack the players didn't respond with "we attack back." If they...

So in this case, the conflicts and threats have been set up by someone else. It's the same thing, really. Whoever comes up with the adventure needs to set those things up; the DW writers probably just assumed that most people would be writing their own adventures. There aren't a lot of...

Neither of these were combat situations. In the first one, the PCs chose to retreat rather than attack or roll for initiative. In the second, there were no hostile intentions; you instead used the narrative to trigger a specific type of countdown, using the initiative system. So neither of these...

So why does it bother them so much to learn that other people have taken those methods of play and given them a name?

According to Wikipedia, it also has "fast-moving tides," which I imagine help contribute to those deaths. You sink into the quicksand, have some trouble getting out, and then drown when the water comes in.

I Made Monsters! Some of you may remember all the monsters I converted to Level Up. Well, here's a bunch for Daggerheart. (I make or convert monsters and the like to help battle depression.) Anyway, confession time: I haven't played the game yet! I want to play or run it, the people at my...

So when the players decide they want to attack, you look at the situation and decide that they don't have to enter combat?

And this is a pretty standard GMing tactic. You know what? I want to know what the structure of one of your games is like. How do you set up conflicts and threats? Do you set up conflicts and threats? Because this thread has a whole lot of heavily-narrative folks going into detail about their...

I'm not trying to trick anyone into anything. I'm pointing out that the things you're complaining about are things you're already doing.

@AlViking, you wanted an example of fail forward from an actual D&D game, so here goes, from last night's game. Preface: I have no idea if the GM adheres to fail-forward principles or not. I know they've run 5e, but I'm not sure they've run anything else, or even fully read any PbtA material...

No. They're guidelines, goals, and the most common things you'll do. That's far from useless. That's far more useful information than you'll get in, say, the 5.14 DMG. OK. Do you understand that most gamers make at least a very minimal map? Personally, I found my games to be a lot more...

Yes, different people run games differently.

No, I read them quite thoroughly.

Except that a reason you don't like narrative games is something that has been a part of D&D forever. Like, literally since it stopped being purely a wargame. So why is it that you're fine with narrative triggers in D&D but not in other games? The only actual difference is that they're labeled...

Um, combat has an explicit fictional trigger in D&D. That trigger is some in-game event that causes the PC or NPC to want to attack, followed by that PC or NPC saying "I attack." In fact, tons of stuff in D&D has an explicit fictional trigger. If the party encounters a locked door and the...