Search results

Other more random comments: Unlike the Basic Rules, where Mentzer/BECMI won out, voters preferred the Cook/B/X version of the Expert Set. (If only by 1 vote.) Does Cook's Expert Set have something going for it that Mentzer's doesn't? B2 Keep was radically more popular than B1 Search, the...

Fair, clarified that. Maybe third-party stuff will be part of someone else's poll...

@Clint_L , feel free to start your more general poll anytime! I can already think of some non-RPG candidates to throw in...

The poll is over! Discuss the results here!

The poll is over! Discuss the results here!

The poll is over! Discuss the results here!

The poll is over! Discuss the results here!

The poll is finished! Here are the 50 best first-party RPG publications ever made for D&D, according to voters on ENWorld! Rank (count) Publication Votes 1st (1-2) Players Handbook (1e) Dungeon Masters Guide (1e) 28 (52.8%) 2nd (3-5) Monster Manual (1e) I6: Ravenloft (1e) Player's...

Two hours left! I'd promote 5e, but seems like it's doing good enough...

One day left! Vote if you got 'em!

You can still vote in the new poll! Less than one day to make your voice heard...

Less than one day left to vote in the poll! If your favorites aren't where they should be, you still have time to make a push...

Day 6 progress report... Top 20 publications: #1 (25 votes): DMG (1e) #2 (24 votes): PHB (1e) #3 (21 votes): I6 Ravenloft (1e), PHB (5e 2014) #4 (20 votes): MM (1e) #5 (19 votes): B2 Keep (Basic) #6 (18 votes): PHB (2e) #7 (17 votes): X1 Isle (Basic) #8 (16 votes): Basic Rules (Mentzer)...

Yup, many new-to-D&D players in our original 5e campaign started off with human characters.

Time to give some likes to 4e! Player's Handbook (4e): A daring reinvention of the game. Player's Handbook 2 (4e): Bringing back some earlier edition favorites! Dungeon Master's Guide (4e): The ultimate guide for running 4e games. Dungeon Master's Guide 2 (4e): More masterful advice! Monster...

I'm very sorry your DM did that to you.

We rather liked Glitterdoom, the first 5e module from Goodman Games, but not sure if it's objectively one of the best.

Day 5 progress report... Top 20 publications: #1 (24 votes): DMG (1e) #2 (23 votes): PHB (1e) #3 (20 votes): I6 Ravenloft (1e) #4 (19 votes): B2 Keep (Basic), MM (1e), PHB (5e 2014) #5 (17 votes): X1 Isle (Basic), PHB (2e) #6 (16 votes): Basic Rules (Mentzer) #7 (15 votes): Planescape CS (2e)...

Just realized the 3e Spell Compendium didn't make it onto the list. Huh. Oh well.

d20 cheers for 3e! Player's Handbook (3e, 3.0): The book that completely reinvented D&D and led the way for the d20 boom. Player's Handbook (3e, 3.5): The refinement that planted the seeds of many OGL games. Dungeon Master's Guide (3e, 3.0): A new DMG for a new century! Dungeon Master's Guide...