Search results

Just a reminder that this thread is for poll candidates - please take commentary to the discussion thread. Thanks!

Agreed!

Fair enough!

Completely serious suggestion: why not make your own thread with that criteria? I'd happily contribute to it.

Booster pack #2 of potential favorites for someone: Tall Tales of the Wee Folk (Basic), one of the first dedicated explorations of fey in D&D Q1 Queen of the Demonweb Pits (1e) Dungeon Master Option: High-Level Campaigns (2e) Living Greyhawk Gazetteer (3e) The Slaying Stone (4e) Eberron: Rising...

More potential favorites for someone: Champions of Mystara (Basic D&D), for fans of the Voyage of the Princess Ark Manual of the Planes (1e), the first dedicated exploration of the AD&D cosmology The Complete Book of Humanoids (2e), the first collection of non-core species Savage Species (3e)...

Prefer not to for this thread, BUT, sounds like a great idea for another thread (or two).

Here's the new thread, with the new plan! D&D General - 50 years, 50 products - candidates

Here's the new thread, with the new plan! D&D General - 50 years, 50 products - candidates

Copying over every candidate from the original thread, in their original order (but sorted by edition): OD&D products: Dungeons & Dragons, the original boxed set. Where the game got its start. Greyhawk, Supplement I for the original D&D game (where the game as we know it really began to take...

Across the 50 years and many editions of D&D, there have been numerous published products for the game. The purpose of this thread is to figure out the 50 RPG products that you, fellow forum members, see as the best and greatest ever made for D&D! I tried this before as a ranked poll, but it...

Sorry, had to close the poll early due to unforeseen issues. More details here. But I will make another attempt!

OK, I guess the experiment is going to have to end early. There are now duplicate products being posted in the list, presumably because some posters can't see what other posters have posted. Sorry everyone! I'd still like to see an ENWorld Top 50, though! I'll try something like @Mercurius's...

Well, there's an issue I never considered. Sorry about that. Still want to finish this out and see how it goes, but do seem to be enough issues with the experiment to be worth a more conventional followup. (Maybe a normal poll that includes every product suggested in the thread?)

Encyclopedia Magica (2e), 4-volume set of all 2e magic items.

Unfortunately, you can sort the poll thread chronologically or by votes, but no other way to organize it and also make it user-defined. That said, as I just tested, you can use the forum's search function to search the thread if you're looking for a particular product.

Guess that answers my earlier question!

D&D Essentials Kit (5e), including Dragon of Icespire Peak.

Madness at Gardmore Abbey (4e)

Wrath of the Immortals, updating the immortals rules for the Basic D&D Rules Cyclopedia era.