Search results

  1. B

    Which non-D&D fantasy RPG do you currently play?

    Currently, Heroquest: Glorantha and Questworlds (generic but in use for fantasy), although the question comes just a few weeks too late to catch Barbarians of Lemuria. The first game started early in lockdown and will soon finish, it might get replaced by Worlds Without Number (but probably...
  2. B

    How do you expect high level play to differ from low level play in a high fantasy RPG?

    My own, still running, most recent experience involved a patriarchal clan where the men and particularly the male leadership was slaughtered and the female leaders were faced with decisions they weren't willing to take about the clan's survival. We played young women, hunters and herders, who...
  3. B

    How do you expect high level play to differ from low level play in a high fantasy RPG?

    I'm not sure I can explain it very well, but I expect, in "high-level" play, for the characters/players' decisions to affect something more than themselves. They might not be the leaders of groups themselves, but they're probably involved with the world in ways that "novice" PCs aren't and as...
  4. B

    I Love Old School Games

    Lejendary Adventures, by one E Gary Gygax, came out in 1999. Old-fashioned even then, though certainly not concise. I think it, like Runequest and Traveller and many others, hasn't had an "OSR" because the current rules aren't so different from the original as to make it hard to convert (some...
  5. B

    I Love Old School Games

    Old School includes AD&D 1e, with 400 pages of rules over the three main rulebooks (and supplements add more). It sometimes includes any game from that era (ill-defined as it is, somewhere from the 1970s to c.1999), which makes Chivalry and Sorcery which was a hefty book on its own. And newer...
  6. B

    With how many people have of role-played with since your first game?

    I've been playing for 45 years, played with multiple shifting groups at university, have run games at conventions and intro sessions at gaming stores, and played with several different groups in long campaigns. I can't guess how many players that is, but it's got to be over 300. I know I've run...
  7. B

    D&D General D&D's feel - forums vs. Reddit

    For several items in that category - and some in other categories too - they've changed several times over the history of D&D. D&D may need an initiative system and/or alignment but which way it's done is entirely debatable and that debate could easily include removing them in favour of...
  8. B

    Alien & Fate Join ICv2's Top 5 RPGs

    Not really how sales of books (I doubt if RPGs are significantly different, it's common across many products) works. Most of the people who are going to but Starfinder already have it, and no other product sells as much as the core rules. General estimate in publishing is that half your sales...
  9. B

    [Chaosium] Paladin • Warriors of Charlemagne

    Similar but not identical to Pendragon 5th edition (I suspect some of the changes are tests for Pendragon Ultimate Edition when that comes out). But they're close enough that you could run a combat between Lancelot and Roland from their stats in the rules without noticing any problems.
  10. B

    Looking for a Fantasy RPG for a small group

    I'd argue that there's many games where this would be perfectly valid, since there's plenty of genres where a pair of adventurers works well. Homes and Watson, for private detectives; Starsky and Hutch (dating myself) for buddy-cops; Fafhrd and the Grey Mouser, for sword & sorcery; Batman and...
  11. B

    Does a Great Axe do 2.5x the Damage of a Dagger?

    It depends where the blow lands, what protection the target has there, and what "important bits" are beneath the flesh. There's a reason why daggers were commonly used for the coup de gras on downed enemies and sometimes friends, after all. What a dagger won't do is batter someone's shield...
  12. B

    D&D 5E (2014) Mapping a fantasy kingdom - sizes and scale

    One option I've used for players is Underground/Metro-style maps. The positions on the map aren't really a close match to how a modern cartographic map would have them, but it would show which direction a settlement/point of interest is, what places you'd pass through on your way to getting...
  13. B

    What's the best and worst D&D book you own from any edition?

    And to some extent the majority of 1970s RPGs don't really qualify as simple (too much influence from 1970s wargames among the writers, I suspect), though equating Old Game with Old School has always seemed unreasonable to me as someone who played in the 1970s. And if the inclusion of a lot of...
  14. B

    What's the best and worst D&D book you own from any edition?

    Best: D&D Rules Cyclopedia, like several other people. Honourable mentions to Eberron Campaign Guide (3e, the 4e one was also very good), Corsairs of the Great Sea (the Al-Qadim line was surprisingly good compared to the OA material), and Havens of the Great Bay (2e, Birthright), 4e Dark Sun...
  15. B

    D&D General Old School DND talks if DND is racist.

    Superior, powerful, treating the inferior races as expendable slaves, and getting away with it. Drow are the Ubermensch. It's not their only property - there's a fetishistic aspect that's been there since the covers of the D-series, "Evil-is-Sexy", and I'm sure there are people who like the...
  16. B

    Looking for a Sci-Fi RPG

    Traveller seems like an obvious place to start looking. I don't think there are any existing adventures that tackle the subject, but there are certainly rules that could handle it (colonisation rules appear most recently in the Tools for Frontier Living from the 2300AD line by Mongoose, but...
  17. B

    Wuxia Campaigns

    Three classic examples from Chinese stories are: 1. Defeat/remove the corrupt - sometimes the Emperor, more often corrupt officials. The adventurers must track down the source of the corruption that is ruining their lives, defeat it, find the next step(s) in the conspiracy and (after however...
  18. B

    Other/new fantasy rpg settings

    The Design Mechanisms Thennla for Mythras is within the timeframe specified, and quite a bit different from typical not-really-medieval settings. It's predictably quite Glorantha-like in terms of cults and magic, but doesn't have the amount of strange magics and races that your find with...
  19. B

    State of the Mongoose 2020

    Depending on what the rules are concerning mixing, I might just finish my Pirates of Drinax campaign over Xmas. It'd be nice to follow up with the very different Deepnight Revelation campaign, since we've had a break from Traveller over most of the year. I don't think it'll happen quite that...
  20. B

    HISTORICAL CAMPAIGNS

    Orbis Mundi 2 is probably the most in-depth coverage of historical medieval Europe/North Africa/Middle East, and does have some depth on Judaism and include a few prominent Jewish characters. There's not much else, though I remember one edition of Pendragon including rules for Jewish knights...
Top