Search results

  1. J

    Describe your last RPG session in more than 5 words.

    I'm calling it 1.2e now because one of the five characters has been rebuilt from being a 1e Ranger into a 2e Ranger. That comes out closer to what the player wanted. The character is a follower of Aldrya, the Gloranthan goddess of plants, fertility, elves and related species. D&D magic-user...
  2. J

    Describe your last rpg session in 5 words

    AD&D 1.2e, Avalon Campaign. Final Fay Lord body retrieved.
  3. J

    Describe your last rpg session in 5 words

    RuneQuest campaign concluded. Lunars defeated.
  4. J

    Should Wizardry Require Player Intelligence?

    No, it shouldn't require lots of player intelligence. Having mechanics that allow it to be more fun for intelligent players is fine. The best example of this which I've played is GURPS Thaumatology: Ritual Path Magic. Designing spells for this on the fly requires (a) thinking of concepts...
  5. J

    Other Modes of RPG Play?

    My experience of asynchronous play is that combat is very slow, and hence best avoided. It also works best with just one player and a GM, so that the turnaround avoids delays. My most successful asynchronous game was playing a character without any meaningful combat ability. He was a jester in...
  6. J

    Describe your last rpg session in 5 words

    GURPS 4e Cold War Pulp Very polite Nazi mad engineer.
  7. J

    If you had to GM your first game again

    I'd leave out one magic item that I'd invented, but I don't think I'd change much else. This was 45 years ago, running the first session in a setting I still use occasionally.
  8. J

    Colossal Space Creature

    The Immortals boxed set for old-time Basic D&D has a creature called a "lith". All liths are planets, but not all planets are liths.
  9. J

    Other Modes of RPG Play?

    Toon is hard to play for more than an hour: the necessary maniac pace gets tiring. A set of modes that I've tinkered with go like this: The classic mode is one GM and several players, with the GM running many NPCs and the players each running one PC. One reasonably common variation has some or...
  10. J

    Describe your last rpg session in 5 words

    GURPS 4e occult WWII in India: Indus Valley Civilization ghosts talk!
  11. J

    What are the primary reasons your players reject other systems/settings/games?

    I never went near it. I want my character information under my own control, not that of a large company's marketing department. My groups are pretty willing to try new systems, and also to give up on them if we aren't enjoying them. One system that didn't get played was Heroes of the Soviet...
  12. J

    For those who have embraced new systems/games, what was the deciding factor?

    My Wednesday evening group has been going over 25 years. It runs two campaigns on alternate weeks, with different GMs, and most of us GM some of the time. In recent years, we've mostly played GURPS 4e, but one of our campaigns is currently Honor & Intrigue. This choice was made by the GM for...
  13. J

    Evil Genius Games Attempts To Remove Bad Press [Update--And Then Adds Legal Threats!]

    It has, however, a lot of "Coming Soon" and "20% off" and seems keen to take money in advance for things to be delivered later. That's something of a red flag from any game company, and from one that's been enthusiastic about blockchains and NFTs, is a huge flashing "caveat emptor" sign.
  14. J

    Describe your last rpg session in 5 words

    Honor & Intrigue, Privateers of the Complications. Caiman attacks and becomes rations.
  15. J

    Describe your last rpg session in 5 words

    AD&D 1e, Avalon campaign: Weird monsters near Fairie's borders.
  16. J

    Presentation and Rules Are Different Things

    I really liked 4e's presentation. It was really clear and legible, vastly superior to 3e. But the rules and ideas were for a game I didn't want to play. I'd bought the slipcased three-volume bundle unseen. I gave it away without ever trying to play it.
  17. J

    Presentation and Rules Are Different Things

    I'm not terribly demanding about presentation, provided it's readable. A few examples of failures on that front: D&D 3e used a graphic background for most pages of its PHB. I'm significantly red/green colourblind, and found the background made reading the rules pretty hard. That was the point...
  18. J

    WotC How much does Hasbro / WotC impact your feelings towards D&D?

    I started playing in late 1979 in college. After a while. it became clear to me that TSR were fairly deficient in knowledge of many fields, and made many mistakes in their rules and worldbuilding. When I started reading Dragon, I saw the contortions they went through to avoid admitting mistakes...
  19. J

    Describe your last rpg session in 5 words

    GURPS 4e Cold War Pulp "Vampire" confesses, Soviet PC leaves.
  20. J

    Describe your last rpg session in 5 words

    AD&D1e, Avalon campaign: Monsters bursting out all over! Alternatively: Blade Barrier fells evil trees.
Top