Search results

That article answers nothing about the edge cases of Action Surge or the Haste spell where you get a second Attack Action. It answers RAW about a single Attack Action (without Extra Attack), and not getting 3 attacks out of it. I think we are all clear on this fact that the Light property only...

I hate how odd numbered stats are useless, so the homebrew rule I use is that Saving Throw modifiers round UP for (Score-10)/2, while all the other existing mechanics continue to to round down. This ends up being a relatively minor impact, at most you gain +1 on some saving throws. But it sure...

WotC going out of their way to give more depth to Martial classes (instead of only giving complex gameplay to Casters) seems to generally be overwhelmingly popular. I don't see anyone here taking offense at your honest question, but you aren't going to get many people agreeing with any take...

The DM can obviously ban whatever they want, but as a player I'd be pretty annoyed at DM specifically targeting martials to nerf them, and would need to consider whether that's really a table I want to play at. Do you also ban Open Hand Monks and Battlemaster Fighters? They've always been able...

Definitely the biggest barrier right here. Better tools to find in person groups is what I would love to see

Do you get a saving throw to avoid being grappled? I thought the saving throw was only as an Action on your turn to escape the grapple (which you already just wouldn't bother doing if you wanted to be grappled) I might be remembering the early playtest rules, I forget whether it got changed...

It's not a saving throw to avoid being grappled, it's an attack roll by the grappler. Seems like you ought to be able to say you want to let them grapple you, but I'm not sure if that's actually RAW Anyways, seems like a bunch of work to do FAR less damage than you could do by just casting...

They can pretty easily both be correct. Pace of play depends almost entirely on the particular players and DM at the table, so one table may say that X speeds things up while another table that same thing could slow the game to a crawl. Makes it pretty pointless to debate about really, other...

I'd assume they meant all General Feats have +1 ability boosts now, which is true.

I LOVE the art layout, for the most part. My eyes can only handle so much text on a page without some color, so I am a big fan of the art being dominant, being highly present, and screaming from the page (to borrow your words above that I agree with other than I view them as a positive rather...

The new rules state that "the DM decides when circumstances are appropriate for hiding", so Rules As Written provide plenty of justification for the DM to adjudicate any gray areas as they see fit without being restricted by hard and fast rules Not that the DM is ever restricted by the rules...

Ok yeah I don't agree with that at all. If the wording was referring to the extra attack of the Light property, it would've been written in the text for the Light property, not under the Nick property. "This extra attack" is referring to the free Nick attack How in the world did such...

Please parse out an explanation of how the wording in the book that says this. I'm not trying to be pedantic here, the wording is very confusing Light states "When you take the Attack action on your turn, you can make one extra attack as a bonus action later in the same turn", which Nick then...

a) You say this like they're avoiding slippery slope by acting early, when in reality they're more like a lifeguard blowing a whistle at an incoming tsunami. WotC can do or say whatever they want, they are not going to become the first company in existence to magically stop internet piracy b)...

My new pet peeve with the new rules is grapple + spike growth cheese grater builds. These existed before and were annoying, but they are going to explode in popularity with grappling becoming so much easier and Grappler feat doubling the cheese grater damage (by no longer cutting movement...

High quality copies will be widely available for pirating soon, no matter what WotC does. Some people are going to buy the book anyways, and some people are going to rely on pirating or just using a copy from another party member. Zero people are going to be like "oh well I was going to buy...

Yeah I didn't say anything about multiple bonus actions. Let's assume a Level 2 Fighter without Extra Attack but does have Action Surge, using a Scimitar + Dagger: Attack Action to attack with Scimitar, use Nick property for free Dagger attack Action Surge Attack Action to attack with...

Ok yeah I see what you mean now, the key parsing is in the Light property (and previously was in Two-Weapon Fighting description), that it triggers when you take the attack action, not when you make an attack Should work with Action Surge or with Haste spell though since those let you take...

Where does it say this? The book says, "You can make this extra attack only once per turn." (bold emphasis mine) I would interpret "this extra attack" to mean the free Nick offhand attack can only be done once per turn, but that it does not say anything Yes or No about using TWF bonus action...

Well say you have a Scimitar in mainhand (MH) and Dagger in offhand (OH). If you have extra attack, couldn't you do: Action, take Attack Action: Attack 1. MH scimitar attack + OH dagger attack thru Nick property Attack 2. MH scimitar attack Bonus action: - OH dagger attack thru TWF