Search results

I will only mention the editions I played, answering three questions: what products are essential to play this edition of the game, in your opinion? What products are highly desiderable to fully enjoy this edition of the game? What products make the game lame and are banned? Mentzer: I consider...

Eyes of the Stone Thief for 13th Age

5) Test of the Warlords (BECMI). You experience high level play, dominions, wars, etc 4) Tomb of Annihilation (5e). Perfect hexcrawl with a time limit, then a deathtrap dungeon. IMO best 5e Adventure. 3) Reign of Winter AP (Pathfinder 1e). You experience being in a fairy-tale, in sci-fic, in an...

1.Dark Sun 2.Ravenloft Red Box revised edition 3.BECMI Companion Set Cyan Box 4.BECMI Basic Set Red Box 5.BECMI Expert Set Blue Box 6.Planescape 7.Forgotten Realms Gray Box 8.Spelljammer 9.Planescape Planes of Conflict 10.Planescape Planes of Law

They are my all-time favourites, of any edition. And yes, they're railroaded, so avoid them if you don't like. I personally enjoy experiencing a good story unfolding. Both are a love-letter to the D&D tradition, especially AoW. Both are very very difficult, designed to challenge optimized...

PHB, MM, DMG. Then Curse of Strahd, Tomb of Annihilation and Descent into Avernus.

Scarred Lands had character.

Dark Sun. Bronze Age + Post-Apocalyptic survival + Psionics + Brom's art

AD&D2e is not a balanced game. Still, it's beautiful

In every edition Dragons are a deadly threat. Visually, I loved the Lockwoood design of 3e Dragons that continues on. I also appreciate the legendary and lair actions of 5e.

Why single-class thief in 2e? If you rolled bad ability scores, you could play thief and still perform great. Also, their exp table meant that they would have many levels more then the other pcs.

Lost Caverns of Tsojicanth is one of my favourites. I've used the module many times. I usually convert on the fly. I think it's appropriate to a Lvl 8-9 party, so use other modules before.