Search results

  1. Branduil

    You primary stat should never be lower than 18

    Yeah, that's the thing that really solidified my view on the importance of having a high primary stat. Heck, if you really needed to hit in 3.x, you just cast True Strike on yourself beforehand. There's nothing like that in 4e, in most cases you just have to rely on the naked roll. The most you...
  2. Branduil

    You primary stat should never be lower than 18

    Right, so 18 is essentially the default target. 16 or 20 are reserved for outside cases; 16 for cases where the synergy with other high stats and available feats make the 16 worth at least as much as an 18 with lower overall stats; 20 for cases like the Wizard and the archery-focused Elf Ranger...
  3. Branduil

    You primary stat should never be lower than 18

    Yeah, the use-your-Int-instead-of-Dex-for-AC thing makes the Wizard even more of a SAD class than it already was.
  4. Branduil

    You primary stat should never be lower than 18

    It's not really a question of viable vs. not-viable. The question is, is an 18 in your primary stat more valuable than a more even distribution? I would say, the vast majority of the time, the 18 will prove to more valuable in the long run.
  5. Branduil

    You primary stat should never be lower than 18

    Possibly, but if he goes sword-and-board, and takes Lightning Reflexes, he can minimize the pain. There's no feat he can take to get back the +1 to attack and damage.
  6. Branduil

    You primary stat should never be lower than 18

    A Dwarf Fighter with Str 18 Con 15 Dex 10 Int 10 Wis 15 Cha 8 is perfectly viable.
  7. Branduil

    You primary stat should never be lower than 18

    Personally, I'd go for the last one. You can pump up Str at every opportunity, and as long as you also up Con a couple times you can still qualify for the feats you're after. The only place you might suffer a little is Reflex Defense, but with shields, items, and the Lightning Reflexes feat you...
  8. Branduil

    You primary stat should never be lower than 18

    I think with some builds it may even be preferable to go for the vaunted 20. Particularly with Wizards and archery-focused Rangers. An Elven Ranger can start off with Str 10 Con 13 Dex 20 Int 10 Wis 15 Cha 8 and be none the worse for the wear.
  9. Branduil

    You primary stat should never be lower than 18

    I think, one of the main reasons to get your attacks as high as possible is daily powers. If you miss with an at-will, no big deal, but the nature of daily powers makes maximizing your primary stat of utmost importance. You don't want to waste a single daily attack power if at all possible, and...
  10. Branduil

    You primary stat should never be lower than 18

    I haven't crunched any numbers, but just looking at it logically, is there any reason to ever have less than at least an 18 in your primary stat? In most cases it seems the +1 to attack, +1 to damage, and +1 to one save far outweighs the more limited benefits of spreading your stats out. You...
  11. Branduil

    The highest-damage fighter power is level 3?!

    I'm fairly sure you're only supposed to get two attacks at most with that power. If you look at all the Ranger powers that give two attacks, in the "Hit" line it always says "x[w]+x per attack." There is no such wording in the fighter power, so I think you only get the first attack, and then the...
  12. Branduil

    Nimble Strike, Careful attack, Twin Strike

    I like the idea of letting you add your modifier to Careful Attack.
  13. Branduil

    Arcane Gate...Best Utility as an Attack spell??

    Now you're thinking with portals.
  14. Branduil

    What's up with Scimitar Dance

    The high crit only comes into play on natural 20s. The +1 to attack applies always.
  15. Branduil

    Where did my options go? - The New Paradigm

    What you call "interesting magic and effects" I call "stealing everyone else's thunder and giving the DM massive headaches."
  16. Branduil

    Corrected PHB2 Class First Letters

    They might save the Monk for an Oriental Campaign book.
  17. Branduil

    Corrected PHB2 Class First Letters

    The List Barbarian Bard Druid I??? Shaman S??? T??? W???
  18. Branduil

    Why the obsession with archer Fighters?

    I think the martial strikers may end up being the default class for newbies. Relatively straightforward powers and you just focus on dealing massive damage to one enemy.
  19. Branduil

    Why the obsession with archer Fighters?

    I keep seeing this complaint and I don't get it. Is there something utterly odious to some people about playing a Ranger? Why not just play a Ranger and call yourself a fighter? I can understand the complaints about the lack of an unarmed melee class, the lack of Druids, the lack of Barbarians...
Top