Search results

Are you suggesting that such ambiguity was purposefully inserted by Gygax (I really don't think so, personally) or that it arose "naturally" from the hostile dynamics between the Keep and the natives?

Do hybrids dream of wrong-eyed sheep?

Monty Python Burglar Sketch

No? I mean, it is a style of play. The 5e campaign that I'm playing in currently (which is nearing its conclusion) is being ran - more or less - with this style and neither I, nor the 5 other players feel that the DM is a "tyrant". Another fine way of playing, to be sure. There are many. Not...

The DMG has this table for NPCs hit points. I would classify peasants as farmers and thus as "laboring".

One factor might be that in the OP you mention Shadowdark. I think that it's a great game and it's very popular, but it is not (and does not want to be) a retroclone.

Wikipedia says that it launched in August 2017 and I've been a member of the forums since March 2017. So, probably, in early '17 the site was up and in August they started selling products.

Personally, I'm not blind to the trend, I simply don't like it. I've got no delusions about inverting it...

I agree. A clone, by definition is a copy, so it has to be as close as possible to the original while offering clarifications and better organization and accessibility. Games inspired by the spirit of older games can be wonderful, of course. They simply are not clones. Ascending AC, on the...

Yes, it is nice to organize a game and use it for video calls, but it is just terrible as a forum. I wish companies stopped using it.

As I've argued already in the thread, you have to decide at character creation to be a bard. It's not something you decide later on and this is why you don't follow all the rules for dual-classing; for example a half-elf, can't dual-class but may become a bard. I don't know, but my...

It doesn't matter, because the character is a bard, not a thief. It means that you roll starting age using the same formula for fighters.

OOC: Is the parrot is exempted?

There is more. In 1e, recovering spells takes a long time. At high levels, you can't unload all your spells and recover them next day. Also, a lot of spells had complications/restrictions that were removed or mitigated. Then everyone started to complain about broken casters...

IMO it is not. Changing to thief is a special thing that bards (and only bards) can do.

Yeah, when I active on DF this one was a recurring discussion...

But the bard is not dual classing so the character does not have to meet the requirement for dual-classing.

There is a pre-bard. What happens with a helm of opposite alignment (or in dozen of other situations one can think up) in undetermined because EGG didn't think too much about this. I also believe that there were few PHB bards in actual play. The only one that I've seen was a character that...

I'm familiar with this position (which is reasonable), but I disagree. You decide to be a bard at the time of creation. You must meet the bard's requirements and the you begin your fighter levers, later you switch to thief and finally to fully-fledged bard.