Search results

  1. thalmin

    D&D 5E (2014) House Rule: Accuracy-Based Critical Hit Damage

    We are just requiring a confirmation roll. Natural 20 is an auto hit, and might be a critical. Roll to hit again, and modifiers. If second roll results in a hit, Crit is confirmed, roll extra damage. If confirmation roll was another natural 20, roll an additional confirmation die to confirm yet...
  2. thalmin

    Jeremy Crawford On The Dark Side of Developing 5E

    He did say largest D&D campaign.
  3. thalmin

    D&D 5E (2014) Encumbrance rule, do you use it?

    I've almost always played in and run games where encumbrance was important, but not nitpicky. In 5E it is one thing that keeps Strength from being a dump stat, and we use the variant rules. It works for my game, and I know my game isn't for everyone.
  4. thalmin

    D&D 5E (2014) Did The Finished 5th Edition Change Anyone's Mind?

    I saw a lot change over the more than 3 years of alpha testing. For the most part, I've only become more impressed with 5E. There are only a few, minor changes I am less fond of. And, no I won't elaborate, as we are still bound by the NDA.
  5. thalmin

    D&D 5E (2014) Mike Mearls' five tweets on the jury duty hold-up

    I would assume that more than just a "stamp of approval" is needed, like maybe an expert check for accuracy or completeness or something..
  6. thalmin

    At Least 4 Months For Conversion Documents

    It is to be noted that WotC is being held to a much higher level of accuracy about release dates than any of the other gaming companies. The much criticized DMG delay was only a couple of weeks, and we were told of the delay about a month out. This for a release date (actual day of the month)...
  7. thalmin

    Give Chase! Expanding the Core Chase Rules!

    But nothing to stop me from adding it!:)
  8. thalmin

    Give Chase! Expanding the Core Chase Rules!

    Good expansion to the rules with very helpful new Complication charts. Just wish the article had mentioned the original DMG page numbers, pp252-255.
  9. thalmin

    D&D 5E (2014) No News from GAMA?

    I don't know where to start. No, not everone can go to get that info. This year I had several conflicts that kept me from going. But the info will be available soon enough. But it would have been better, for me and my store and for WotC, if I and all of the other retailers had gone there...
  10. thalmin

    At Least 4 Months For Conversion Documents

    What is expected in a conversion guide? Just one generic guide to work for every module ever written? A guide for each editon's module. A guide for each module? Not every class or race or monster is yet in 5E, so we need different substitutions. Most monsters are either stronger or weaker than...
  11. thalmin

    D&D 5E (2014) So, 5e OGL

    If there was some breaking news, why would anyone break it buried on page 52 of a thread, where only a tiny handful of peaple would see it? I would start a new thread if I had such a scoop!
  12. thalmin

    At Least 4 Months For Conversion Documents

    I agree that I would like to see the conversion documents last month. I would also like to see Wizards publish monthly short modules. Possibly in addition to printing updated classic modules. But I can only hope. I do know that WotC is working on something beyond PotA, though I don't know what...
  13. thalmin

    At Least 4 Months For Conversion Documents

    You are assuming the jury person has nothing better to do when not at the courthouse than approve the conversion docs. We don't know what other responsibilites (s)he has that might be more important, like possibly the next (unanounced) 5E book, or maybe a family. It's much easier to believe it...
  14. thalmin

    D&D 5E (2014) Convince me to Spend the Money

    Try to read an entry or two in the Monster Manual. Not the stat block, but the information about the monster. That gives a good indication how they are approaching the game, where story is at least as important as the mechanics.
  15. thalmin

    D&D 5E (2014) Swimming in armor

    Never tried swimming in armor (never owned any) but I have swum fully dressed. When I was a Boy Scout working on my Swimming Merit Badge, there was a requirement where we had to jump into the water fully dressed (long pants, long sleeve shirt, shoes). The regular requirement involved removing...
  16. thalmin

    [UPDATED] Issues With Official D&D 5E Spell Cards?

    Battlefront is the company, they make Flames of War, which is rules and 15mm minis for WWII combat. Battlefront acquired Gale Force 9 several years ago. I don't remember if it was before or after GF9 started to make the vinyl D&D maps.
  17. thalmin

    D&D 5E (2014) DMs: How Old Are You?

    You've got me beat! I'm just 66, but you and I started playing and DMing about the same time. I'm surprised no teen DMs. I know several, even a pre-teen DM or 2. I guess they don't spend much time on the boards.
  18. thalmin

    D&D 5E (2014) Improved Find Familiar

    I would not allow it if another player was a warlock. As for overall balance, I think having the wizard attuned to an imp or such would work. And the higher level familiar could always still break the bond, just like with the warlock
  19. thalmin

    D&D 5E (2014) Semi-sandbox product I'd love to see

    That would be L1 not B1 And I agree, fun module with a nice town, interesting surroundings.
Top