Search results

  1. Cloudgatherer

    Powerful Master Harper PrC?

    I think I have yet to see a Bard PrC that was considered overpowered....
  2. Cloudgatherer

    Auto-Quicken Spell + Multispell + Time Stop + Wish = Cheese (Time Stop+Wish Argument)

    Re: Re: Auto-Quicken Spell + Multispell + Time Stop + Wish = Cheese While this is a variant presented in the ELH, one of the old rulings stated that this was not the case. You could leave the X fireballs hanging in the air and yes they would all "hit" when TS ended, dealing their normal...
  3. Cloudgatherer

    Rules Enforcement Poll

    Option 2 also. I'm a big fan of consistency. If the enemies are playing by a different set of rules, then it detracts from the fun, IMO.
  4. Cloudgatherer

    My Diviner is taking spell focus: evocation. What do you think about that?

    I have a feeling there will at least a couple spells in 3.5e that are diviinations that involve a save... And I never found spell focus to be unbalanced at +2. I had a hard time with +4 from GSF, but not with the regular +2 version.
  5. Cloudgatherer

    Casters Nerfed, Melee Ascendant (3.5)

    This is true, but giving up 3 spells to have +6 to all save DCs and SR checks is a rather small sacrifice. Yeah, the archmage has fewer spells, but those spells are much more powerful.
  6. Cloudgatherer

    Casters Nerfed, Melee Ascendant (3.5)

    While I agree with this, there is an issue of comparable characters. Take two spellcasters who choose different routes, one archmage (or other spell power class), the other not (assume same party). If the archmage boasts better DCs and is more effective in combat, how does that look for the...
  7. Cloudgatherer

    My Diviner is taking spell focus: evocation. What do you think about that?

    Someone going for archmage? SF (divination, evocation) as prereqs?
  8. Cloudgatherer

    Revision Spotlight: Two spells...

    Are they doing away with close range cones? (25 ft + 5/2 levels)
  9. Cloudgatherer

    Casters Nerfed, Melee Ascendant (3.5)

    Uh, yeah. I did one in this thread a few pages back... it's missing the Spell Focus nerf.... guess I'll go add that. (page 2) Edit: Since I'm here... Did I miss anything?
  10. Cloudgatherer

    D&D 3.x 3.5 Spell Focus gives only +1 to DCs

    Seems to make the Archmage PrC just that much more valuable...(powerful?)
  11. Cloudgatherer

    Ever play a PC of the opposite gender?

    I played one once. Got some odd questions about it, but my foremost reason for doing so was I was about to start a campaign of my own. All the NPCs wouldn't be male, so I might as well play a female in a quick campaign to get used to playing a female character. Ironically, she was a female...
  12. Cloudgatherer

    Ring of Mindblank-How Much?

    By the rules (guidelines), it would cost 240,000 GP. 2000 * 15 (min caster level) * 8 (spell level). Of course that's only the suggested starting price, and it can be modified up or down by the DM. Later.
  13. Cloudgatherer

    PCs that start the game as 1st level NPCs -- good idea?

    I'm just going to say I don't think it is such a good idea for reasons already discussed. Personally, doesn't appeal to me (quite the opposite).
  14. Cloudgatherer

    New Default Setting: Forgotten Realms?

    Red Wizard and Archmage, FR PrCs are being put into the DMG. Where are the examples of the Greyhawk specific PrCs? Maybe they are there and I do not recognize them by PrC name.
  15. Cloudgatherer

    New Default Setting: Forgotten Realms?

    I guess there is a difference between saying something is the official gameworld and something else actually being the official gameworld... I mean, where are the books? GHCS, Magic of Greyhawk, Races of Greyhawk, or similar books simply aren't around. While we might be "told" GH is the...
  16. Cloudgatherer

    Players' Poll - Splitting the Party

    Bad, even when in the RPG world it would be a "good" idea. Bad from the DM's perspective because now he has to run simultaneous timelines. Also, what happens to one group doesn't affect the other (and the other group might be sitting there, listening). Bad for players because, even assuming...
  17. Cloudgatherer

    Forcibly Removing Armour

    How about the rules for doing damage to an object? Just break the armor right off of him...
  18. Cloudgatherer

    Ki Feats?

    Why concentration? What do Monk's use it for?
  19. Cloudgatherer

    Who/What are your campaigns big villains?

    Hm... mine had several villains.... Silven Nightmantle, a shadow adept, plagued the party the most. He often fought indirectly, taking control of other NPCs and throwing them around as a distraction or as meatshields. At first he had no interest in the party, but because they opposed him on...
  20. Cloudgatherer

    Casters Nerfed, Melee Ascendant (3.5)

    While wall of force will completely shut off a section of the battleground, Forcecage can allow a caster to "trap" an opponent *and* pelt him with ranged weapons and spells. An incredible advantage over wall of force, hence the level increase and cost. I'm not saying Hyper's interpretation is...
Top