Search results

  1. T

    D&D General me finally making the big monk discussion thread

    I always think the attachment to the supernatural with monk is such a strange thing since it's supposed to be all mystical but you can go all the way up to nine levels of monk (base class) and still be indistinguishable from an unarmed martial artist. If anything I'd say the name should be...
  2. T

    Playtest (A5E) Level Up Playtest Document #10: Adept

    I don't have a real problem with the name "Adept" but it doesn't evoke any feeling in me (that is, hearing the name fighter tells me they fight, hearing the name berzerker makes me think they'll go berzerk, hearing the name wizard or sorcerer makes me think of casting spells). Since the Monk...
  3. T

    Level Up (A5E) What would you call a 'Warlord' class? (+)

    I'd think Commander for if it's a charisma class or Tactician if it's an Intelligence class. Banneret is also good but obviously it's like mastermind in that it's already the name of a subclass.
  4. T

    D&D General Let's Talk About How to "Fix" D&D

    I want: 1. Meaningful decisions at each level. 2. More non-magical options (I went through by subclass and counted 17 options (out of 112 total) that I could consider nonamgical (and that's if you consider the zealot's radiant damage force-of-will and the base monk's ability to turn invisible as...
  5. T

    D&D General Let's Talk About How to "Fix" D&D

    Fun Fact: The milestone XP variant in the DMG is not "Level Advancement Without XP: Story-Based Advancement," which is a separate section right below milestone XP. (I understand that milestone means just levelling up whenever in the vernacular, it's just that ACTUAL milestone XP is a ruleset...
  6. 1613078565203.png

    1613078565203.png

  7. 1613078520386.png

    1613078520386.png

  8. T

    Playtest (A5E) Level Up Advanced 5E Playtest Document #9: Warlord

    I've always found this one funny (even not having played 4e) because you can't 'Cure Wounds' a severed arm back on either, only restore HP. In 5e to heal a severed arm you'd need to be at least level 14 before you can cast 'Regenerate'.
  9. T

    Official News Level Up: Let’s Talk About Archetypes

    I can instantly tell what all of these are meant to play like just by reading the list (which I consider good design) except for: what is the difference between a Traditionalist Wizard and a Mage? Also nitpick but if you have a reason I'd like to hear why you made a firemage instead of a...
  10. T

    Playtest (A5E) Level Up Playtest Document #8: Berserker

    Looking good, just gotta wonder a few things: If you take Juggernaut, does it mean you're basically choosing to give up your rage feature? Furious critical looks fun, but it's an awful lot for something the player has no control over. Will fearsome reputation come with a table of random...
  11. T

    D&D 5E (2024) Fighter Class rewrite

    If you want it to come across as a stance I have a suggestion: " When you dodge while at maximum HP you may make a weapon attack as a bonus action." Dodging as a bonus action is a big buff, but if it requires max HP to bulwark that really lowers the times when you can use it. I'd see some folks...
  12. T

    D&D 5E (2014) How would you improve monsters?

    First, gotta second (and third, and fourth, and fifth) that 4e should be a major source of inspiration. Second: Each monster should have at least 3 abilities and at most 6 abilities (maybe more that are purely utility). Name some abilities and give them levels like spells if they seem magical...
  13. T

    Level Up (A5E) What would you *call* an Advanced 5E?

    Not a suggestion but I do like the ones that abbreviate to A5e. "Apotheosis of the Fifth Era" type stuff.
  14. T

    Level Up (A5E) Any plans to fix Two weapon fighting in Level up?

    That being said, at least in-play I tend to have a two-weapon player in all of my games and haven't seen a rogue who isn't two-weapon. Don't think it's underpowered or overpowered, but it has a niche that it seems to fill pretty well.
  15. T

    Level Up (A5E) Any plans to fix Two weapon fighting in Level up?

    Smite makes TWF better because smite makes all melee paladins better. TWF paladin sounds like a pretty cool concept thinking about it. And the shortest work day in all the game. I'd say TWF is par right now. If you made it part of the attack action it would be too strong without first nerfing...
  16. T

    Level Up (A5E) Any plans to fix Two weapon fighting in Level up?

    Yep. If you have the fighting style it's another standard attack. If you have the feat you get +2 damage and +1 AC. If you have neither it's still another damage die every turn. The bonus action seems like a fair balance to keep it from being OP.
  17. T

    Official News Class Balance In A5E: How Much Damage Should A Damage Dealer Deal?

    I mean to say casting a levelled spell as a bonus action forbids casting one as an action. That would require over 3 turns
  18. T

    Official News Class Balance In A5E: How Much Damage Should A Damage Dealer Deal?

    I think I'm missing something but cleric has four levelled spells cast.
  19. T

    Level Up (A5E) The Advanced Fighter

    +1 to hit for every 3 Fighter levels. You want something that comes online early so you can feel it but that makes it worth it to stay Fighter instead of dipping, right?
Top