Search results

Me to, but since we chose D&D we got the mystery that is hit points. That is why I feel the 5e's Damage Threshold works well with the concept of the 4e minion. I do not believe that was the intention. Crushing their shin with a mallet thus rendering them prone, and practically immobile and...

I'm of the opinion this came down to the understanding of the game. Those that ran it for me and even when I started running it battled because of our lack of understanding, I feel.

I do not agree, since I consider both obstacles to be overcome by the PCs, not that I'm in favour of doors having their DCs changed depending on the PC's level or the area's level, funnily enough. I prefer more consistency on that issue. I quite like having the freedom to treat monsters as...

Bold emphasis mine. These do not naturally occur. They occur by design. i.e. Design leads to having us play solve it at higher levels.

4e got a lot of criticism from the sim crowd about how the opening of doors supposedly had shifting DCs depending on one's level on this very forum. I cannot remember the outcome of those debates but if the opening of a door DCs shifts because of the ever-changing math as your character...

Yes, the designers did a poor job. I use a combination of tools to assist against such sad outcomes, some of which are Hit Points I have a table for how hit points are calculated and they are dependent on if the creature is a standard, elite, named etc Touch Attacks for ethereal creatures...

Bold emphasis mine. Just keep in mind about the game you're referring to...and why and how the math changed.

No I do not see the difference. See below. I imagine I'm not alone when I was playing 1e-3e where there were good and bad NPCs and they were fighting I would use DM decides as to what happens, thereby degrading the NPCs as I see fit. And then when the PCs intervened I would not make those...

Who is in charge of designing monsters and challenges for the encounter? And how is that different from ANY D&D game where the GM changes up the monsters and challenges? When a GM changes up a 5e monster per WotC published material do you call that a serious house ruling? Do you ever have good...

I think it is because it is easier to just create a minion monster for an encounter than deal with the game repercussions of walking deities.

I do not think the disparity of hit points between minions and others was an issue for 4e. I'm not sure sim was a concern given math of the game. What do you mean by groups?

Particularly hard is subjective. Skill Challenges were formalised in DMG2. Half the usual playable races and classes were in PHB2. The issue of how things were released in 4e is not new, but I do not think you can draw the conclusion you have drawn. Let's move past the goblins shall we? The...

Ok, I replied to Lanefan who was making the case that the lich's stats did not change from level to level when you encountered it. It was not a comment about appropriate creatures based on level. That is great lore for a weaker form of lich. I'm sure you agree in that that the vestige is very...

I do not have an issue imagining a high-level warrior using mortal strikes against 3-4 ogres

My point exactly. If your argument against the minion concept is using a Lich as an example, then you do not understand the purpose of the minion.

I can see a high-level warrior wading through ogres with clean efficient kills, it is a less likely occurrence happening with a cluster of liches I feel.

Using that technique what would make them a minion? The idea behind my changes is that the fighter would still wade through if they did enough damage, but that smaller amounts of damage would not suddenly drop the creature.

2e until till 3.5e Man that was so fortunate...I'd have been highly annoyed if I had picked up 3.0

I'd say we are spoilt for choice right now (regarding tools we can use), fortunately.

This is true. During the early days of 5e / the D&D "Next" phase I had the table experiment with capped HD based on size (Medium = 6, Large = 10....etc). Resistance and Damage Threshold could also be implemented. I mean that if i wanted to pick a part the fiction of D&D I have an issue with...