Search results

  1. D

    D&D General When a character dies and a new one arrives

    Looks for "New character tears it's way out of the old ones corpse, screaming for revenge and covered in it's predecessors viscera." ... ... ... No? Not an option? Same level then. (You get the behaviour you reward. If you penalize the players for the characters death, you wind up with...
  2. D

    D&D General What elements should D&D keep? forums vs. Reddit

    Since obviously no one else is going to say it... Thank you OP. That was probably a fair amount of effort and work to do for our benefit, and I appreciate it.
  3. D

    Sticking with the wrong group for longer than you should.

    If the whole group gets along and I don't? The problem isn't them, it's me.
  4. D

    D&D General On Grognardism...

    I am not a them! I are an us!
  5. D

    D&D General On Grognardism...

    I have been on that tour! I loved going on the Croaker. I loved the sample doorway in the waiting line with the sign (paraphrased) "If you cannot move through this, do not go on this tour." And "Space was so tight, nobody could take a shower until the food stored in the shower itself was...
  6. D

    D&D General On Grognardism...

    I think the number of people who genuinely think old (or OSR rules) are written better than 5E rules is very small. Because ...welll... they aren't. But they do support a very different play process/experience. And some people enjoy that. A typewriter will never be as efficient and versatile a...
  7. D

    D&D General Damage by class instead of by weapon-anyone tried this?

    Damage by class instead of by weapon-anyone tried this? Well...Dungeon World, for one.
  8. D

    Worlds of Design: Which Came First, the Character or Their Backstory?

    If players give me background, I will tie it into the campaign. If they don't, then it is assumed there is nothing exceptional in their background to speak of. "I am Bruce the Fighter. I come from the North" is fine if that's what the player wants. If I want to tie them into the "rebellion in...
  9. D

    That Thread in Which We Ruminate on the Confluence of Actor Stance, Immersion, and "Playing as if I Was My Character"

    I'm not sure which side of the debate you are actually on, but whichever one it is you are wrong and the way you play is bad.
  10. D

    Word help -- area sizes!

    Ok then. "Territorial"
  11. D

    Word help -- area sizes!

    Have you considered moving Region down a step and making the top area "Territory"?
  12. D

    D&D General The mentality of being a DM

    Entertainer and party host. I am there to show the players a good time. No tactic or technique - including bald-faced lying to them about what my notes say and what the dice-behind-the-screen show - is off the table as long as it accomplishes that goal.
  13. D

    D&D General Filling the Gaps

    Hit locations, in a way that enables cool actions but doesn't devolve getting wounded into a gruesome torture-porn death spiral, without relying on DM fiat. (Even as a DM)
  14. D

    D&D General Most Memorable Party Win

    Ending Strahd by repeatedly refusing to be drawn into his castle (where he is at his strongest, what are we MORONS?), and instead drawing him out - we knew we were being scryed - by putting on a very public and very obscene puppet show with him as the main character. On open ground, driven by...
  15. D

    How often do you enforce laws in your games?

    Player characters don't even obey the Law of Gravity. Why would they sweat something small-time like theft or murder or serial arson-in-a-twenty-foot-radius?
  16. D

    Make Your Case: Two Great Things You Need to Recommend

    Do Podcasts count? "Mission to Zyxx". A mostly improv space opera that lovingly lampoons all the usual geek stuff we aren't talking about. At times very very funny. As with most improv, a big part of the joke comes from the actors trying to throw each other off stride. And then I want to...
  17. D

    How to Tell if Your Fun is Wrong

    Nothing done at a roleplaying gaming table should be judged by any other standards or criteria than "Do all the players in that game agree to it."
  18. D

    D&D General Friday Fun: Merge Two Monsters

    Bee-Holder It's like a regular beholder, but full of bees. So even if you defeat it...BEES!
  19. D

    D&D 5E (2014) Cantrip nerf (house rule brainstorm)

    If you must have a limit, just pick a high but still measurable number of cantrip "slots" per short rest. 10 x Proficiency Bonus/short rest would work. It satisfies the conceptual space of "not being unlimited", without impacting actual play for anyone but low level Bladedancers and Warlocks.
Top