Search results

The only people who care about how games "rank" against each other are folks like us around here who have no financial stake in the games... only our own egos wanting the games we prefer to be the "popular" ones. As though it legitimizes our opinions as being correct. No one who actually...

Not having ads broadcast after every single song/video is played I'm sure for one. ;)

I mean that's what games like Champions and Mutants & Masterminds do. One mechanical system that you can use to build any character you want and can fluff it any way that you want. But they also have "classes" to a certain extent, which are just pre-made and pre-bought hero concepts (like the...

Sure they do. The Battlemaster is a swordmage. But the designers just chose to fluff the magic as "combat maneuvers". ;) Someone wants a gish? Just refluff all the combat maneuvers as magical effects rather than combat actions. Because at the ends of the day that's all any of these game...

Just for funsies a little while ago I did my own "What would the game look like if we removed Constitution?" write-up... and substituted 'Perception' as the CON replacement ability. So the third physical stat was now all the sensory (and extra-sensory) organs taking in information, and thus I...

I just saw on ex-Twitter that D&D Beyond announced in their new update that they have now added checkboxes on the first page of the character creator to allow you to enable or disable the five different options of rules sources-- the 2024 Core Rules, the 2014 Core Rules, Expanded rules, Legacy...

If this is such a simple and elegant solution, then why did you bother coming here to make a thread just to tell us that your player was bummed about it? Cause that doesn't sound like the solution worked. Which means it wasn't simple and elegant at all. I mean if the point of the thread was...

Traditionally, the staff of a just-released set of core books tends to leave upon the books' publication (either voluntarily or with a staff lay-off within the next year or so). We then see a turnover in new employees come in to shepherd the new game forward for quite a while, and then maybe in...

There are no rules specific to this situation. Probably because this is a prime "Rulings, not rules" area where there's no reason for WotC to make a hard and fast choice for everyone when each DM can make the decision on their own.

That is true. But I suspect people might question-- were you in this same situation as @ECMO3-- whether "testing the system" was a more important thing than letting your player have fun and be happy? Now granted, in your current situation I would imagine your players are all in with you on...

One of the issues of treating low stats as some sort of "character flaw" of course is that "low stats" don't actually make your PC all that bad. Not when you are adding up to 20 points to any check you make using the d20. Even if your INT is a 6 and you have a -2 modifier... in theory a...

In theory... although I found that having a Flaw that was described with a sentence, rather than just a singular word of belief or attitude was more difficult for players to "act". Assuming of course a player was actually interested in "acting" in character in the first place. Which is not...

I do not tend to rely on just the six ability scores to find the particular flaw or hubris my PC is going to have that will be fun to roleplay. Rather, having played the original 7th Sea for many years in several campaigns-- where each PC takes a specific Hubris that can be activated by the GM...

I submitted mostly Green for everything. The only specific place where I was a hard Yellow were the four Disciplines that gave bonuses to paired spell schools. If you look at the schools that the Psion's spells come from, there is a HUGE difference in the numbers. For 1st and 2nd-level spells...

Yup. Exactly. Heck, to support your thesis, the Warlock is no different than the other casters either, even with their "different" spellcasting format. Between each Rest the Warlock will cast a couple powerful spells and a whole bunch of cantrips... which is exactly what all the other casters...

I would imagine its because WotC probably determined most of their millions of players care more about ease-of-use and the story results of using a feature than needing more unique mechanics to acquire and organize those features. Once a player determines that the story of who their character...

Heh heh... it probably would have come down to how many times as the guy who did Sage Advice he had to deal with people sending questions and comments about how pact magic worked and whether it was actually balanced or not. ;) After all, we still get all kinds of complaints about the "balance"...

If you are talking about the play test attempt to make the warlock a standard half-caster, they might have done that not because they thought pact magic was a mistake, but just that so many people kept asking for an arcane half-caster that they were curious whether more people preferred it over...

The change in spine away from the red might be a conscious decision by the team so as to not have people treat books released after the revisions as "5E24" books... which therefore would perhaps subconsciously make customers think that all the books with the black spines were now old and no...

How dare you namecheck Stroker Ace but then use a GIF of the Bandit! THEY ARE TWO SEPARATE CHARACTERS!!! I SUPPOSE YOUR PC HAD A COMPANION NAMED CAPTAIN CHAOS TOO, DIDN'T YOU?!? SHAME!!! CROSS-CASTING YOUR BURT REYNOLDS MOVIES LIKE THAT!!! SHAME!!! :D