Search results

Wow, nice try at that straw man! I can cast magic missile as a 5th level spell that will do average damage of 13 points vs flurry average damage of 42 if all my attacks hit. If only half of my flurries hit my damage drops to 17. 3rd level spells is 3/day at six level vs 18 disciple points used...

Thank you. That is a well thought out and reasonable post. Many could learn from your example. 👍

Apparently we are because you bring martials into it. I comment on your post and you complain. Typical martials must have it all posts.

Easy dude. Can I flurry a magic missile spell five times? Are all flurry attacks automatically blocked by a simple first level spell like shield? Talk about goal posts, you are off the field.

Oh please. Having a strength is different than completely negating an ability. There is no 1rst level spell that is an auto win button that cannot be countered at all. If spell casters were so overpowered then no one would play a martial. D&D is NOT a pvp game. That being said no power should...

Yes, unfortunately they are. The Vecna adventure is worse as it’s a level after every encounter. You never get to play with your toys anymore. The designers do NOT know how to run adventures anymore. It’s a bunch of exposition and background the a fight or two the in to the next chapter which is...

Then you play in different games than me. Strength or Intelligence are often the default dumps for monks in my groups as they have little to offer and most strength checks are done by a dex check equivalent such as acrobatics for athletics checks. The whole point of finesse weapons is to get...

Yeah dude, if you dump stat strength you are a weakling. Does not matter if you are a monk or a wizard. You are still wearing robes :D

That is objectively not true since there are 2nd edition lines that have not been reprinted such as Dark Sun & Birthright, Mystara.

Better than generic monsters that get hacked down and have lost the flavor they had for 5 editions. They also would suffer from trolls u that half damage from a coup de grace won’t be fatal. Silver or magic weapons or spells would be required to finish them off.

I find this odd as a criticism of 2nd edition was too many campaign settings that split the player base.

lycanthropes should have half damage from normal weapons but require defeat to be administered from a silver weapon, magic weapon or magic. Perhaps give them fast healing 10 that is reduced by spells, magic or silver weapons.

The reason you don't engage with goblins and orcs from a geopolitical standpoint is simple. Their societies do not function at the same level. They never seem to rise above the hunter/gatherer stage in most D&D settings. I have seen the orcs of Thar and a mention of Throtyl in Dragon Lance but...

Perhaps they should have had a section in the monster manual exploring Drow culture if only for the reason that the Drider makes no sense now as a monster inclusion. Just a small blurb about Dark Elf culture in Dragon Lance, Forgotten Realms and Greyhawk worlds.

I can make the exact same argument for a lycanthrope. Even then there is no such thing as complete immunity. Martials can get silver or magic weapons so your comparison falls flat.

So you think that the Rajshahi is unfair to casters then? Should it lose its heightened magic resistance?

Wow! I didn’t even notice that. That is ridiculously overpowered! So my barbarian can shrug off a massive giant’s club or a Dragon’s bite but a wimpy monk yell “Wah-Pow!” and cuts right through my defenses? Thx for nothing WOTC.

I really dislike the loss of immunity to non silvered or magic weapons. I would at least give them resistance. It seems like the monk and warlock abilities to do magic damage are now class ribbons instead of useful abilities.

I must say as a DM, D&D Beyond is amazing. I use the maps and tokens to play with friends over the internet. Encounter build is a huge time saver whether playing in person or online. It would be perfect if you could have your campaign notes linked in a format like World Anvil. Even the dice...