Search results

Out of curiosity why aren't the spell cards listed for 5th edition?

For Forgotten Realms you could use Luskan or Neverwinter.

So you are ignoring the fact that you are getting what you want "warforged" in a timelier fashion then the previous edition and for cheaper. Yet you have still found a reason to complain about it. What am I missing?

The problem with talking about future endeavors is that if it doesn't come to fruition or it gets delayed people go nuts. Just look at what happened when they "cancelled" the Adventure's Handbook, many people freaked out. While I would enjoy more communication from them about upcoming projects...

This reminds me of the Evermeet book from 2E where the Queen had an army of soldiers in "sleep" to be called up on when their need was most dire. While they were living soldiers who chose to be put in magical sleep for centuries to help protect the elves, it definitely shares some similarities...

LMoP was most likely written before the treasure tables were created, so it is completely understandable that it doesn't conform to it.

How does the fighter have 4 attacks at 12 level as you don't get the 4th attack till 19th (unless they are using two weapons).

I pointed out in my post that a DM can't always say yes, but they should be looking for ways to say yes. My point was that if a DM is always putting the kibosh on players ideas (if you are saying no significantly more then yes) then there is a problem. Too many times in threads I see people...

Actually, it seems that you are looking for a reason to say no. Anytime someone brings up a character option you have to try and pick it apart as you believe that they are min/maxing or that they could play something else that is similar but not the same. Looking to say yes is something very...

You are looking for a reason to say no though. You haven't given one reason why MC shouldn't be allowed besides that you don't like it and people "might" min/max. That is it, and while it is your right to not allow it in your game, you have hardly articulated a good reason why it shouldn't be...

First problem I have is that it isn't the DM's game, it is the groups game, and you come off as being very adversarial and are attaching a motivation to all players that want to MC when you are simply incorrect. Not everyone who wants to MC wants to min/max and to attack all players as only...

I would say that not letting players know in advance if you can sell magic items is part of the problem, and the fact that you keep wanting to say the player made a "mistake" is pretty telling on how you are blaming them but are not taking any responsibility for the lack of communication.

^This.

If you didn't tell the player ahead of time that they couldn't sell magic items, then he made an assumption based off of rules that he could do it. You are trying to blame the player as if it is their fault instead of taking some responsibility for not communicating it in advance. This isn't a...

What you state is true for a "common" person but we are talking about a scholar/sage (and a PC which means he probably travels significantly more then any common person) not a common person. What is the point of the background if they have to encounter everything to know about it? What did they...

How often new characters are created is up to the group. Some groups will take characters from level 1 to level 20+ and some groups rarely get past level 10 before creating new characters and starting a new campaign. Now if you are doing a story arc like Tyranny of Dragons then I would expect...

Technically you don't need the MM or the DMG (and you don't "need" the PHB if you are using the pregens) if you are running the starter set adventure (though it might be nice to have them). Not everyone needs a PHB either, 1-2 per table is usually fine though if everyone wants to have one that...

In my group the Fighter with Plate +3 and a Shield +3 would never in a million years also get a bracers of defense or anything else that helped AC as the other party members would want it. You are right, if you take the single best magic items from the DMG and give it to a single player then...