Search results

It got to page 3? I'm impressed, the mods must have been out for tea that hour.

I bet an edition survivor would be popular. It would probably cost the lives of tens of thousands of people, but it would be popular. :D

Avariel 13 Drow 1 Eladrin 24 High Elf 29 Sea Elf 7 Wood Elf 31

Avariel 19 Drow 11 Eladrin 22 Grugach 3 High Elf 25 Sea Elf 12 Shadar-Kai 7 Wood Elf 32 honorable mention to the Basic Red Box Elf

Let me pop open my old brown B1 and see what I picked in 1982... Room 1: 3 shriekers/ 7gp Room 2: goblet worth 15gp Room4: 7 kobolds/ 500gp necklace Room 5: 7 orcs/ box with 35gp and a 100gp gem in trapped drawer Room 34: 3 zombies guard 2450 cp HA! Also in the back you get 48 characters...

I'll take more classes and fewer themes. The only class I'd like to see take a 2e approach is the Cleric.

need? none Worry about getting the classes right before we worry about a hundred different ways to make an archer.

wizard, paladin, cleric, priest (other), sorcerer, other arcane (invoker), ranger, druid, warlock, knight, warlord, bard, elf and avenger

I'll vote the Joan Crawford "NO ARCANE MAGIC IN ARMOR EVER!!!!" At least in the basic game, some mechanic can be added for the more complex versions.

co-signed Yet another poll that looks like an Italian Parliamentary election result. Level is just an organizing principle, the key is WHEN the teleporting, disintegrating and Google level scrying begins. (along with the martial class whining and teeth gnashing :hmm:)

Unless 5E is going to have just four classes, they belong.

You were playing with Rick James?

Correct on all points, 1E Paladin is one of if not the best D&D class of all time. As Henry Ford once said, "You can play any kind of Paladin you want so long as it's a Lawful Good Tithing Holy Warrior in a suit of shiny armor and riding a magic horse."

Popularity, tradition and the money WOTC will make from exploiting those two things. The head designer will say to his team, "We need a Paladin (or Ranger/ Monk/ Bard/ Assassin), come up with some mechanics for it." It's a top down business decision not a game design one. You'll also need a...

I have a vision of D&D designers huddling in the corner and weeping. I fear it's just a bridge too far.

I've never been able to get away with banning multiclassing, but I keep hope alive. Assassins have been banned from my table for thirty years. :p

Tradition, money and they are both vastly more cool that your average fighter. Hopefully, if I pick the right options, I can have a Ranger with spells once again. I think the fighter/ cleric does infringe too much on the Paladin, but my solution is to get rid of multiclassing.

I confuse and infuriate the rest of the world. :p

A little, hopefully WOTC will obey all my whims and have 5e just the way I want it right out of the box. :D

It should be the default RAW. Gritty fights with house cats should be relegated to optional status.