Search results

Good to hear. [/b] Whaaaaat? Who was running Great Gerhardt, anyway? This can't be right! :p [/b] On the other hand, I am really starting to like Gjord. [/b] Great Gerhardt leaves a well populated dungeon, no doubt full of creatures to slay and equipment to loot, to carry a Cleric back to...

Face it, Fighters are just another NPC class. If you want real power, always go with a caster.

Wizardru is correct about my point of view. Alignment is what you are. Judging people based on their alignment is judging them based on their actions, since their alignment is determined by their actions. By the way, I do not think characters like Scrooge would be classified as Evil. Such...

I want a link to the site where that comic came from and I want it now. :D

Bane. Pfffft. Now Torm, there's a deity.

Thanks for the information. I agree, this show rocks.

Deleted.

Deleted.

I could just as easily say your stance would lead to never judging evil and taking action against it until it was too late, because they "might", one day, turn out good. In any case, I question why one would leave clearly evil creatures to their own machinations until given the chance to commit...

By the way Trainz, what do the rest of the PCs think of the situation? I would make sure I have their support before taking action, as the last thing you want is the Rogue sticking a sword in your back when you make your move.

I already answered this question earlier. We are going about in circles here. To me, the bottom line is the Kobolds represent a threat to the town of Oakhurst, which coupled with their evil alignment demands the Paladin take action against them. The Paladins first duty in almost every case is...

That is evidence of evil. In fact, it is irrefutable proof of evil. That is the whole point of the spell. It can be fooled, but that is obviously not the case here. They are evil humanoids who pose a definite threat to a nearby community of innocents. It is the Paladins duty to see that...

I just noticed Honorwolfs avatar. A munchkin even in fighting games. Sad. ;)

One month, two days, and counting. By the way, since you ran adventures in Westgate, you might be interested in this thread: http://www.enworld.org/forums/showthread.php?t=65104

Act with honor. Even if the former Paladin had not become an Undead creature, her comrade still would have been leaving her body to rot and decompose, with no burial rites of any kind, no respect paid for her great sacrifice What the Paladin did is one of the least honorable actions possible.

What exactly do you view Detect Evil as, anyway? To me, it is a divinely granted gift from the Paladins deity that allows him to peer into ones very soul. Given that, if a creature detects as Evil, I would say the Paladin has every right, by the book, to slay them, especially if they pose a...

I realize fully what kind of Paladin that leads to. It leads to an adventuring Paladin who is effecient and a valued member of a party. Yes, you can slay people based on Detect Evil. It is a guide, yes, but it provides irrevocable proof (in most cases) of the state of a beings soul. Good and...

The evidence has already been presented. The divine gift to Detect Evil given to Paladins is there for a reason, you know. The Paladin should already be suspicious of the Kobolds, and of the Dragon. His ability simply confirms what is already apparent. The Paladin should not wait for evil...

By the book, the Paladin should kill the Kobolds. I can understand the other points of view on the subject, but they are not by the book. Based on the facts that the Kobolds are evil, are raising an evil White Dragon, and could pose a significant threat to the residents of Oakhurst in the...

The core code of the Paladin should be adjusted to take into account the deity he serves, however. Two of Torms greatest precepts are Duty and Loyalty, and the Paladin grossly violated both of them by leaving his fellow Paladins body in an Undead ridden graveyard. He should be immediately...