Search results

  1. Paul Farquhar

    D&D General D&D is now Steampunk (poll)

    Well clearly, since The Culture isn’t medieval, it must be Steempunk.
  2. Paul Farquhar

    D&D General D&D is now Steampunk (poll)

    As already pointed out, steampunk is Victorina. If the fashion in the art is not Victorian, its vibe is not steampunk. For example, the recent Eberron art is inspired by the early 20th century - Georgian, not Victorian. Ergo it is not Steampunk. Steampunk is a Science Fiction subgenre...
  3. Paul Farquhar

    Spoilers King & Conquerer

    Yeah, I felt exactly the same about Last Kingdom. I have no interest rooting for some jerk whose problems are largely of their own making. And this was a completely fictional character, so he is only a jerk because the author wrote him that way. As for William, he was pretty much the trope...
  4. Paul Farquhar

    Spoilers King & Conquerer

    But to me, it doesn't look like it's doing a Braveheart. It looks like it's trying to stick to what is in the record but making silly mistakes. Nothing is changed for a reason. There isn't much known about Harold's character, and what there is is mostly Norman propaganda. So there was a real...
  5. Paul Farquhar

    D&D 5E (2024) Thoughts on Infinite Staircase?

    It’s arguably the best of the original stories (and the last written I think). If you have read the module you will know the gist. Conan and Valeria stumble into an advanced lost city and meet some degenerate cultish survivors who are locked in a deadly civil war. They end up all killing each...
  6. Paul Farquhar

    D&D 5E (2024) Thoughts on Infinite Staircase?

    Conan story that was the original inspiration.
  7. Paul Farquhar

    D&D General D&D is now Steampunk (poll)

    Top hats and bustles? Nope, not seeing any of that. What we are seeing are two things. A recognition that all that magic the PCs wield must have an effect on the society they live in. I.e. Magitech, which is most definitely not Steampunk. And a recognition that since D&D fashions have never...
  8. Paul Farquhar

    D&D General D&D is now Steampunk (poll)

    Sure. That's fine. But don't try and claim that it's medieval unless you are actually doing medieval. Call it genericfantasyland or something.
  9. Paul Farquhar

    D&D General D&D is now Steampunk (poll)

    And my point is all these things are equally not remotely medieval, but they are all very much D&D. This thread is all "I am going to define something that is not remotely Medieval as Medieval and complain that it is turning into something that I am going to call Steampunk even though it is not...
  10. Paul Farquhar

    Spoilers King & Conquerer

    The problem is, it looks like its trying to be historical, and failing. Wolf Hall deliberately put a different twist on the history-what-everyone-knows, and thereby is a worth watching TV show. This looks like it's just doing a bad job at regurgitating a tired history lesson. Lucy Worsley...
  11. Paul Farquhar

    D&D 5E (2024) Thoughts on Infinite Staircase?

    Yeah, I think the person doing the update must have read Red Nails beforehand to get the feel.
  12. Paul Farquhar

    What makes Arthurian fantasy its own genre, different from more traditional D&D-ish medieval fantasy? What are some Arthurian-style plots?

    I can't believe you missed out Monty Python and the Holy Grail! I'm not sure how you are connecting Name of the Rose with Tristan and Isolde. The later is a mythical story stet in the time of Arthur (whenever that happened to be), whist the former is a 20th century historical fiction novel with...
  13. Paul Farquhar

    D&D 5E (2024) Thoughts on Infinite Staircase?

    It's a really good collection. Good original adventures updated skilfully. I've only run Barrier Peaks from it so far (and Lost Caverns in ye olden days).
  14. Paul Farquhar

    What makes Arthurian fantasy its own genre, different from more traditional D&D-ish medieval fantasy? What are some Arthurian-style plots?

    Whilst I wouldn't disagree with you, I think you may be overstepping the forum's "no politics" rule there.
  15. Paul Farquhar

    What makes Arthurian fantasy its own genre, different from more traditional D&D-ish medieval fantasy? What are some Arthurian-style plots?

    The thing I noticed, having seen the Disney movie long before reading the book, is I had assumed that all the silliness with sentient mustard pots and time travelling anachronistic Merlin was down to Disney. But nope, it's in the book.
  16. Paul Farquhar

    What makes Arthurian fantasy its own genre, different from more traditional D&D-ish medieval fantasy? What are some Arthurian-style plots?

    There are a lot of different versions of Arthur. He has been around for a long time, and when his popularity swings around again he is reinvented to suit the period in which the stories are being told. So the answer is: anything you like.
  17. Paul Farquhar

    Deathstalker Gets A Reboot!

    This looks very meta to me. Like its deliberately trying to look like an 80s B movie.
  18. Paul Farquhar

    Spoilers Alien: Earth Spoiler Thread

    You don't need a robot to turn ultrasound into frequencies audible to humans though. A common bat detector does that. It's possible, I guess, that the calls are being deliberately targeted at Wendy.
  19. Paul Farquhar

    Dungeons & Dragons Releases New Unearthed Arcana Subclasses, Strongly Hinting at Dark Sun

    If humans behaved rationally to conserve scarce resources they wouldn’t be in that situation in the first place.
Top