Search results

If we were discussing a new game, with which I had no history, I might very well agree with you completely. In fact, I would even go so far as to say that the current iterations of D&D are slightly more conducisive to a point buy system. However, the game doesn't exist in a vaccuum, it comes...

Vlad Taltos from the Steven Brust Dragaera novels (Jhereg, Yendi, Teckla, etc). If you haven't read AT least the first two (Jhereg & Yendi) you should.

I'd say go Half-Orc Barbarian/Fighter...with enough Fighter levels for the extra feats to round out your character (at least 4 levels for Weapon Specialization, but I recommend 6th level to get the extra feat and bump to your saves). Go with a 2h weapon, crank your strength and go the power...

Nah, just felt it was off-topic so I would stick it in its own reply so it stood alone from the point I was trying to make. I would agree with that.

I'll happily list my weaknesses and limitations, but just as happily list my strengths. Overall, I think it's a valuable part of being a person of honesty and integrity.

You make some really good points, and I can't disagree with most of them. However, I think your points and mind can coexist and represent the strengths of both sides of this situation. I play D&D largely for the random character creation. It's not so random that I'm limited in what background...

I agree that if someone takes their monster stats and makes a one trick pony, they're going to be overall more well rounded and capable. However, since we are talking about all characters being made with the same point buy, I think it is a fair analogy. Again, I'm not saying Point Buy is a...

I guess I just can't agree with requiring Point Buy for reasons of "balance." I think it allows some classes to shine, some classes are largely unaffected and a few classes are forced to mediocrity (with a low to average point buy, 28 or so). But, obviously, you guys are free to play however...

A small pouch full of salt Some dried clay that could be rewet, molded and dried into specific shapes. Or just rewet and molded to fill small cracks, etc.

Borderline Fantasy... Count of Monte Cristo The Three Musketeers The Man in the Iron Mask Not Fantasy, but quite inspirational... A Fist Full of Dollars For a Few Dollars More The Good, The Bad and The Ugly Once Upon a Time in the West

Out of curiosity, how do you reconcile this with the fact that I can make a MUCH more effective wizard or sorceror on 28 point buy, when compared to someone elses Monk or Paladin? In order to make a monk or paladin really shine and be very enjoyable to play (both classes are arguably...

More good suggestions, let's keep 'em coming. I'll add two more. 4 thick, but long leather belts Hammer and Pitons (15)

I've made it clear that I'm all in the "roll d'em bones" corner of this boxing ring. However, I would like to add a caveat. If you are stuck in a situation where you are forced to play with people who you just flat CANNOT trust to play by the rules. You may have better luck with point...

10 feet of wire Some "coin sized" iron slugs.

This is a good start guys, but let's see some more. I know there have to be some great ideas floating out there that I never thought of including in my gear. How about... Flask of high proof grain alcohol Hammock made out of net More?

QFT If the DM says, we're doing 28 point buy, have characters ready by Friday. I guarantee you, I'm going to get more mileage out of my Sorceror's stats than you're going to get out of your Monk's stats with that point buy. Cedric

The 10ft pole thread got me thinking...what 'essential adventuring equipment' do people make certain they have with them? Now, while you can obviously list certain magic items, but I was aiming more towards mundane (and maybe sometimes exotic) items that you may or may not have a specific use...

And I agree completely, that's a problem. If you feel that way, then something needs to change because, honestly, that's just not fun. As to my thoughts on balance. Eh, I'm old and stuck in my ways. I didn't like the fact that 2e watered down mages...and I didn't play mages back then. So I...

Ultimately, what it comes down to in regards to Glass' position (as far as I can tell) is that Glass does not believe the PHB and MM are at all ambiguous regarding this rule. He believes that the PHB and MM are quite clear about NOT allowing Monk's to take INA. Therefore, since no ambiguity...

That's your opinion, many of us loved it and embraced the lack of balance. And regardless what character I've played in high or low level 1st ed D&D, I've contributed to the overall success of the party because of my skill as a player. I may not have thrown down as many dice as the Arch Mage...