Search results

  1. A

    Does anybody else miss 1st L Characters

    It seems that every incarnation of what we play is full of power creep.I'd like to see real true 1st L chars again 4th has them w/ as much as 40 HP, Pathfinder has them dealing huge amounts of damage.How often is ANY char made that does not have at least 1 18.When I had decided on switching away...
  2. A

    In Defence of D&D: The "Good Enough" System

    I think the OP has hit something right on the head,but its a djinn thats already out of the bottle at this point.The split on 'what is D&D'is prob permanint at this point.Im not sure a 5th is going to be good enuf for anybody.I hope Im wrong.In my own case,I switched to Pathfinder,but am open...
  3. A

    How Many 1st Level Fighters Should a 10th Level Fighter Beat?

    30 I dont know why other than I want to be in the majority for this poll
  4. A

    Fifth edition should be base-twelve

    um.....just no
  5. A

    A Vital Issue

    please tell me this is an unfunny joke?
  6. A

    Core Classes: What and how many

    I voted for Invoker but it could easily be a cleric subclass,warlord and avenger could be subs of fighter or paladin Not sure how I would go w/ this if it were my decision to make Prob put6-8 classes in each of 2 books
  7. A

    Irresponsible use of magic and other WMDs

    I gave my son a wand of unlimited unseen servants,thinking what harm could it do,he can only have one at a time. He proceeded to kill them.Repeatedly.Always.Constantly. It drove the rest of the party nuts.
  8. A

    The Awful and Dangerous Monster?

    I dont think any RAW is going to present monsters that work perfictly due to party compasition,as always it will be the DMs job to beef up or tone down.
  9. A

    Swords,Maces n stuff

    Wow,I really wasnt expecting any support on this....
  10. A

    Swords,Maces n stuff

    Ok I know this would add a layer of complexity to 5e but let me throw this out there-- What if weopon groups each had some reason to use them for example: Swords +1 to hit Maces -some kind of bonus verses metal armour Axes-highest damage spears-best criticals I know it will never happen but I...
  11. A

    Skill-linked monsters (defeated by skill checks)

    raise dead on one of my favorite threads... I just ran a cave flled w sages who were killed byathletics or dungeneering,religion(prophasy-sound familier?) and arcana (severing the soul,The summoner started quoting"Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom' B+ encounter Just love this Idea ERIC...
  12. A

    Dungeon graffiti

    What a GREAT thread,Im yoinking all of it and subscribing!
  13. A

    What in the world is left to be in core?

    $X$ would not be satisfying from a cost/sales pespective I think more like 8x8
  14. A

    Yer candidate for the monster on 5th MM1

    Beholder w/eyes a BLAZIN
  15. A

    Making Magic Magical Again?

    keep vancian but.... add crit hit/miss for spells add 'pushing"w/o metamagic looser description of spells allowing them to be used in differant situations(feats?)
  16. A

    In my wishlist: Minions

    The way to do this is to use a modified swarm.This way you can have an epic fight w/ huge numbers of baddies,Ive done this in every version of D&D/Pathfinder and is very satisfying
  17. A

    Non-Vancian Caster Option

    as long as we have vancian,you guys can have whatever you like!
  18. A

    To Hell with Dungeons & Dragons ! ! !

    I am ashamed to be in the same hobby as you!lol?(Not so much)
  19. A

    D&D 5E (2014) Can 5E bring the wonder and mystery back to Magic Items?

    I agree w/most of this but as a DM my old grognard brain always forgets what an item does when I dont tell the player right away....but yours would be a perfict world!
  20. A

    Why we need Warlords in D&DN

    although healing is part of it ,I actually like the fluff and roleplaying aspects of warlord,I dont care if they heal or give temp hp,its the JOB that turns me on!
Top