Search results

moved post to proper thread

No response is.... not a good sign. (Perhaps not posting for a while is a better move? The mods have definitely seen the request so...)

PS there is a new character creation guide, posted by the facilitator account (cause that's best practice). It significantly expands (not so good was already long) a lot of issues that have come up over the past few days (good?). Please provide feedback if you can.

Eladrins are like awesome though (15th or 25th or something?)... So maybe they kill the drow and the elves all hide behind their skirts... :p Seriously that's a very good point though.

> I vote that anything in the hardcover books is ok. Not voting! Just discussing. ;) Seriously though, glad to hear peoples thoughts. We've seen one actual adventure submission so far (all props to Halford). Cov is helping me work out mine. So... that's.. two. And I can say that it's not a...

You may also communicate through email, just email l4w.judges at gmail.

This thread is now 16 pages long... which is intimidating... do we want to think about a new thread?

Silvi says "moving around the base of the cliff should not be hard, it is steep and difficult to see from the top" Just waiting for RC to confirm the action, and any last plans.

Very true. Yay merciless destruction of our foes! Go us!

You see... that's the kind of argument that I think you can just take too far. Like when people kept arguing in KK1 that Come-and-get-it was a shift because of a funny word choice and thus did all this stuff that it obviously, by design, wouldn't do (i.e. give everyone else in the group a free...

Personally I could see "lowering" gith levels. I have a harder time for some reason making Illithids heroic tier. (maybe because they were heroic teir in 3.x and it just didn't work, they were like speed bumps...) But I don't see why Gith can't be around 5th... They'd kick butt compared to...

elecgraystone it wasn't exactly a proposal... I'm not sure that I want to run a vote on every item... Since there's no consensus yet I'll but my comment (posted before i saw egs's comment) in a sblock) We could allow AV say "just pick from that", but DMs will almost certainly want to create...

The judges have been discussing new magic items. We seek input. Please share your thoughts with us.

So... the judges have sorta been talking about magical items. Per the voting so far players can only use stuff from the PhB but we haven't technically decided what DMs can use. Of course, as a story element the "magical boat that can take you to the Ilse of the Faires" or "the Elvin Kings...

go ahead ren, gaming waits for no approval, we'll get it squared away.

That's what we're trying to establish.... Palindrome's mentor is an arcanist, he could easily 1) assume magic is involved 2) want to find out more Woe may be connected because he has an existing relationship with Palindrome going back to something that happened 10 years ago. (I leave it up to...

I hate to put it this way... but if you don't know.... I don't think anyone knows. My theory would be that its a lot like being chucked through a cloud of daggers, no save. The whole pushed->pits->free save thing is because deep pits and lava are all insta-death. I *don't* think it extends...

you can play exactly one character in l4w... Right now anyway (if/when it changes it will be at least a few months) be careful about picking something to try to fit the current composition I'd suggest playing the character you're most excited about and leaving yourself in ere's hands. My...

Gith are interesting. They are flavorful and interesting; they have a lot of what WotC calls "traction" They generally fit... poorly in game settings. You can't play them in FR, in a way that really connects well with the setting. They work good in PS (but so does everything) They were...

Thanks for the enthusiasm. If you're a mystery expert I'm doubly looking forward to getting your input on the adventure then... Complaints would be endemic I think. Even people who like the Screamer feel obliged to talk about how terrible it is. Woe could have been involved in Mayor Bunt's...