Search results

  1. F

    Which edition of D&D gets the most heated discussions?

    I, for one, have never noticed exceptional fervor around 1e discussions. Now that you call them out, I'm sure they must exist, but they are just not on my radar. I think we're all most sensitive to arguments against our own favorite edition. I would posit that many of us think that Enworld...
  2. F

    So I Want To Run A Western Game...

    Boot Hill! As soon as I can get out of this rocking chair and find my teeth, I'll get the neighborhood kid to go through my attic and dig up the rules ...
  3. F

    More "realistic" advancement in D&D?

    All excellent points! I'll let you know how the sessions go.
  4. F

    Hinting of Secrets and Enticing Players to Explore

    This. I don't place things pre-game so much as I have things that I place as soon as the PCs look. "Oh, that demonic fountain? Why yes it does conceal a secret ..."
  5. F

    More "realistic" advancement in D&D?

    Off topic, but which was the first one in? Fat or skinny?
  6. F

    Module Layout: what's important to you?

    Smart paper, where I can touch a monster's name and pull up a stat block. :) FWIW, I hate the Wotc's 4e "separate the dungeon map out into little chunks." But my taste in map layout is probably betraying my age. For my money, there was never a better adventure map than Caves of Chaos.
  7. F

    Warhammer 3e Demo Experiences -OR- How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bits

    Well, Asmor's convinced me to buy a copy of WH3E. I don't have it yet, but I already wish you could buy more dice separate for the core rules. Amazon willing, it should arrive in time for a couple new years games.
  8. F

    More "realistic" advancement in D&D?

    Not advancement, but related to the OP ... One idea I've been toying with is having monsters do their level in damage when their attacks miss. If HP really are "luck, divine providence, endurance, blah blah," then ducking a blow or blocking a strike should wear you down a little. Blocking a...
  9. F

    More "realistic" advancement in D&D?

    Or, if you have the old first edition AD&D DMG kicking around, you could use the old training rules for level advancement. If memory serves (and it probably doesn't) didn't it also cost gold for advancing? Or was that just the justification for 1 gp = 1 xp? I'm in an airport w/o access to my...
  10. F

    Pathfinder 1E d20 Modern Patronage/Pathfinder Project

    I'm sorry to be dense. Is this an revision of d20 Modern, or a Modern game built off of the revised Pathfinder "engine"? And yeah, not that you are counting votes, but my $$$ go for 4e modern. It would seem well suited for modern cinematic mayhem.
  11. F

    Dark Con, Phoenix, AZ

    Have to get a room at the hotel. No other way for full con immersion. I'm hoping some enworlder has attended. I'd love to hear a con report. But just supporting a convention in the West is a worthwhile endeavor.
  12. F

    Dark Con, Phoenix, AZ

    Wow, what a terrible site ... ... which can only mean this con must rock. I'm dying to attend. Wonder what flights into AZ are like. Any idea the number of attendees? 5k-ish?
  13. F

    Music for a Cyberpunk future?

    Seconded. Of topic: what game system? Also off topic: The Springs have a great punk tradition in the face of the Air Force Cadets/Family Values contingent.
  14. F

    Why was morale removed from the game?

    I'm sure it is just fog of age, but wasn't 1e tailored more for "we hire 6 spearmen from town to come with us and carry our treasure, all for 1 share of the treasure plus first pick of the magic items, as long as we outfit them with gear first." Whereas 3.x+ was about the party being unto...
  15. F

    The Temple Between - Grand Cathedal Combat

    I don't have the Scales of War, but would it be possible to hand off the allied "monsters" to the players?
  16. F

    I need coldweather monsters!

    FWIW, here is the Elmore image I was thinking of. http://www.larryelmore.com/images/paintings/elmore_p056al.jpg
  17. F

    3E & 4E Love and Hate Polls - What does it mean?

    Obviously we need a divorce settlement. 3.x can take Enworld on Mondays, Weds, and Fridays, and 4e gets Tues, Thurs and alternating Weekends. We trade off holidays, but my mother would really like to have the gang over to throw some dice for Christmas. Reason: Irreconcilable differences. ;)
  18. F

    I need coldweather monsters!

    Not level appropriate, but I just came across this awesome image on the Wizards site. Rip off of an old Elmore composition, but awesome just the same. http://images.onesite.com/community.wizards.com/wallpapers/wallpaper_04-1280.jpg
  19. F

    Do you need more dice?

    I think the distinction that I make (and maybe others) is that the dice aren't like normal "semi-random number generators." They move, in my mind, from general tools to tools with a specific purpose. My 10 dice I use exclusively for L5F, my emerald d20 I use for running 4e games, my smoke d20 I...
  20. F

    Death Dealer Adventure?

    Mispost
Top