Search results

  1. Tav_Behemoth

    The Essentials articles are atrocious.

    Since the most tolerable was written by freelancers rather than staffers, but is still not as good as the guides that were written by fans, I think you mean to say that hiring in general is not working out for Dragon! Seriously, I see that this is a topic that folks feel strongly about, and I...
  2. Tav_Behemoth

    The Essentials articles are atrocious.

    Having co-written the Warden Essentials article, I'm interested in how the series is perceived. Here are some things I can say: 1) The comparison with video game guides is inappropriate because a guide doesn't alter the way the video game functions. As others have pointed out, the Essentials...
  3. Tav_Behemoth

    What 4e does right

    I agree with the OP that the concept of attacks vs. different defenses are a simple and intuitive way to resolve conflict. It's easy for everyone to agree that a fear spell or a sanity-blasting apparition is an attack vs. Will, while a poison or a stinking cloud spell is an attack vs. Fort. I...
  4. Tav_Behemoth

    Starting "Old SChool" gaming

    I agree that one of the things I enjoy about 4E (or 3.X with a group that has a high level of rules-expertise and has been playing together long or well enough to work out consensus) is that it's clear to everyone what will happen in a given situation. When I DM, I can rely on the players to...
  5. Tav_Behemoth

    Starting "Old SChool" gaming

    I play in some of the PbP games at the OD&D board linked above, and while they're great I don't know if I'd get an 'aha!' moment from them as easily as with face to face play. Where do you live? Are there local conventions or gamedays where you could find a game for hands-on experience? You...
  6. Tav_Behemoth

    Recomend me a product.

    I think you're thinking of [http://www.rpg.net/reviews/archive/14/14511.phtml]People of Pembrooktonshire[/url] and/or its companion module, No Dignity in Death: The Three Brides.
  7. Tav_Behemoth

    NYC-specific resources for gamers seeking gamers

    Redirecting a thread from General, here's some tips for folks wanting more play in and around NYC: The NYC D&D Meetup group is the world's largest D&D meetup and is more or less dedicated to 4E. Their next large-scale event is Nov. 7th at the Compleat Strategist in Manhattan - join the meetup...
  8. Tav_Behemoth

    Player looking for a group in New York City!

    Here are some resources for NYC players: The NYC D&D Meetup group is the world's largest D&D meetup and is more or less dedicated to 4E. Their next large-scale event is Nov. 7th at the Compleat Strategist in Manhattan - join the meetup group and RSVP if you want to play then and/or use their...
  9. Tav_Behemoth

    Warden Essentials

    As long as I don't get turned into a female named Allison Tavis, I'm OK with that (as Nifft said for me below!). I actually kind of like the idea that, like Iain Banks writes mainstream novels but Iain M. Banks writes SF, I can have one alter ego that does stuff for WotC and another that...
  10. Tav_Behemoth

    Fantasy Monk Styles

    The names of the powers for Forgotten Heroes' monk use a couple of monster styles. The one that comes to mind is the Manticore style, which involves fighting in melee and then suddenly hurling the (not usually throwable) weapon you've been fighting with at an enemy - inspired by one of the...
  11. Tav_Behemoth

    NYC, NY: Swords & Wizardry/OD&D looking for players

    At Gen Con I played in a great old-school adventure, full of mystery, danger, problem-solving, and rich ancient-Egypt-themed atmosphere. The author is planning to work it up for publication, so I'm looking to gather a group of intrepid adventurers to set foot within the newly-unsealed tomb...
  12. Tav_Behemoth

    An OD&D-style 4E game?

    Since the original edition of D&D was a game of adventure, exploration, and narrative-building that borrowed the rules of an existing game of miniatures combat when it wanted to resolve a fight, I've been attracted to the idea of using the framework of an early-edition D&D ruleset for everything...
  13. Tav_Behemoth

    What version of D&D are you playing?

    Mine are in my sig - I'll check with this post to see if that's updated! Looking forward to playing OD&D and 4E at Gen Con - also I guess the NASCRAG tournament uses 3.5, although I hardly pay attention to the mechanics.
  14. Tav_Behemoth

    Non Linear Mega Dungeon

    I like to warn PCs of things - dangerous areas, traps, deadly monsters - by leaving the corpses of other adventurers around. It helps the dungeon have a sense of history, so that it doesn't seem like a pristine set-piece that was just waiting for the players to arrive, and it's a naturalistic...
  15. Tav_Behemoth

    [Wed] Original D&D (1974 edition)

    I've decided on a start time - 6:30 pm Wednesday evening - and place, at the Ram. Reveal, it'd be great if you could update the meta-thread accordingly! It's possible we'll eventually move on from the Ram, so if you're interested in playing but haven't gotten an email from me, send me a PM and...
  16. Tav_Behemoth

    [Wed] Original D&D (1974 edition)

    That'd be great, Lanefan! I was just thinking about how to determine starting level. Rolling some number of d6 x 100 or 500 appeals to me because I like random chargen, I dig the way old-school parties often included PCs of different level, and I think it'd be just as interesting & valid in OD&D...
  17. Tav_Behemoth

    Suggested Reading: Issues 1-250

    "D&D Options: Orgies, Inc." in Dragon #10. Worth it just for the title, and the Trampier illustration, but also a very interesting take on the old-school gold for XP idea.
  18. Tav_Behemoth

    [Wed] Original D&D (1974 edition)

    A crowd is good - my 0E game in NYC often has a dozen players - and other folks (my roommate) will be dropping in later as well, so that's all good, Mark.
  19. Tav_Behemoth

    [Wed] Original D&D (1974 edition)

    I'd like to get a group together to roll up some fighting men, magic-users, and clerics and set out on some fantastic adventures playable with pencil and paper! I'm thinking about running Paul Jaquay's classic adventure Night of the Walking Wet, for mid- to high-level PCs, but if folks know that...
  20. Tav_Behemoth

    Registration for Gary Con II Open!

    Me too! I look forward to seeing you (and Luke and Diaglo) again.
Top