Search results

I believe there is a general rule o thumb among casual players to not allow a few things. Dragonmark feats for one have been banned in every game I've played. I can't think of any others off the top o my head.

Just to clarify there are a billion things pcs can do but enemies can't. I'd hardly say Blade barrier and command are alone in that regard. And to clarify my point... Enemies don't need to be able to do anything pcs can. Think the Demigod lvl 30 feature: "ZOMG the Runescribed Dracolich ran out...

Yeah, this class would make everyone else obsolete. It would no longer be "what class are you. it would be "what mc do you have with Mercenary." I'd also like to point out that there are currently no classes based on motivation. They are all based on HOW they do things, rather then why. The...

just fyi, if you make the healing surge triggered use by a deathblow landing a immediate reaction, you still screw over defenders as they are typically the only role that use immediate actions regularly. Free action gets the job done just as well.

Yeah, it only makes sense. I would think it odd for an artificer to pull out a spiked chain and understand more about operating it with his arcane magic then he could while holding it. And also since it doesn't specify that the weapon is proficient with itself, I feel its a pretty clear cut ruling.

I'm not all that versed in your version of "literature" so don't expect me to appease you. And anyway, its quire ridiculous to claim that interpretation of a D&D rule requires a reference from an arbitrarily decided genre of literature to remain plausible. Rules is rules, what Aragorn did or...

yes, you could read it like that. You could also read that bolded part as the Government having a legal obligation to solve your marriage issues. But it would be idiotic to do so. More to the point, RAW can mean many different things based on how you define your terms and read a sentence.

Well... yeah, if you only allow 5 or 6 books under your definition of "literature" sure an example of many things couldn't be found in there.

resist 5 pretty much eliminates any damage a minion could do, as well as negates any damage from ongoing 5 effects. I'd be REAL hard pressed to say that -2 to attacks is better than resist 5. maybe if you are dealing with more than 3 controllers or several stun sources in an encounter, but...

it came up in a game I DM'd.... sooo... yeah. Guess how it was ruled. :)

I think its totally within the right of the DM to fudge rolls. The trust isn't that he won't its that he won't to the effect of making the game less fun. I roll in the open, but I totally feel that my group would not refuse to play with me if I didn't. That shows a tremendous lack of faith in...

Ok, my educated interpretation. I would say it does include your proficiency bonus but not include the proficiency bonus if you don't have one. Nothing indicates that the weapon is proficient with itself, which is usually stated when discussing proficiency bonuses for self directing (or things...

I really really doubt you are going to get any more direct official ruling on this then you already have.

I can't imagine Mirtul plays with friends, because to mistrust your DM so inherently would indicate a pretty terrible friendship imo.

PHB 1: pg 232 under Thrown Weapons 1st sentence.

But there are other issues with a Goliath Seeker, the stat bonuses are very subpar. Almost as bad a race/class combo as you can get. None of the racial feats are very good for the seeker class. Also the Seeker really needs some good range on its powers, many of which are limited by the weapon...

Well all magic weapons when thrown returns to your hand at some point before the start of your next turn (again, with the hangover i do not remember exactly where I saw that or when it happens, but I am very very sure about that.)

MoG.

I can't remember where it is, but I'm 75% sure there's a rule that states the power that "wins" is the higher level one.

1. yes. 2. yes, but they are all conditional. There is one for thunder powers, but im not sure the name.