Search results

  1. Ferghis

    Power retraining question

    Retraining a feat to the same feat with a different effect is certainly allowed (arcane familiar, for example). Retraining a power to another power you could have chosen when you originally the power is also kosher. But if a feat simply says you get power X from class Y, you can't retrain that...
  2. Ferghis

    Warden AC Gimped Defender ?

    I agree that both Superior Will and Font of Life saves coul be used to try to remove a save-ends daze or stun effect on the same turn. These are extremely debilitating effects for a defender, and some of the most frequent effect creatures impose. Further, many even consider the effect "unfun."...
  3. Ferghis

    How Bad Would the Game Get Fraked if...

    Please let us know how it goes, how the players react to and use the option, and what it gets them, if anything.
  4. Ferghis

    Recommend me an adventure

    I haven't played them, but before starting a long-term published-adventure campaign a short while ago, the DM and I discussed what was well reviewed and what wasn't. War of the Burning Sky was very well reviewed, and takes you from 1 to 30. Earlier adventures need updating to MM3 numbers, but...
  5. Ferghis

    Warden AC Gimped Defender ?

    As pointed out above, it more than stacks. I suggest taking it before Focused Discipline, which is also very useful.
  6. Ferghis

    Critical Hits with Power Strike and Corroboration

    I can't say that I agree with AbdulAlhazred, even though he knows this game very well indeed. I don't see what difference it would make that it's a separate power or a class feature. Power strike might even be both. And warlock's curse is a power, but those dice get maximized. Since we're...
  7. Ferghis

    Channel Divinity Cleric - what exactly does "another use" really mean ?

    I see. So, nobody has a source that clarifies this in any meaningful way?
  8. Ferghis

    Channel Divinity Cleric - what exactly does "another use" really mean ?

    I'm not sure I understand, since all CD powers are encounter powers.
  9. Ferghis

    Channel Divinity Cleric - what exactly does "another use" really mean ?

    I don't necessarily think it restores an expended power. My initial reading was simply that it let me use my channel divinity power again. As in, I used it once, and now I get to use it again. However you want to phrase that is fine by me. It's an additional use. I want to say that I don't...
  10. Ferghis

    How Bad Would the Game Get Fraked if...

    Well, within limits. The rules do suggest burning surges is fair game in skill challenges, and otherwise suggest penalizing or awarding surges in some situations. So I wouldn't describe the idea as "terrible."
  11. Ferghis

    Channel Divinity Cleric - what exactly does "another use" really mean ?

    Odd, I never read it that way. Admittedly, if they wanted you to regain the use of a channel divinity you had already used, they could have said just that. Aside from the possibility of a clearer wording, is there a clarification that they have posted somewhere about this? Or some other reason...
  12. Ferghis

    Warden AC Gimped Defender ?

    Polerarm gamble is excellent close-quarter control (which is what defenders do), but won't you be keeping the targets out of your mark range, if you do that?
  13. Ferghis

    How Bad Would the Game Get Fraked if...

    This would resolve most of the issues I was highlighting. This is probably the safest way to go. I've been trying to figure out how to use athletics to gain an extra square of movement. My rather unexamined idea is this: This makes it so that characters who are already very fast have a bit...
  14. Ferghis

    How Bad Would the Game Get Fraked if...

    First thing that comes to mind is that they can turn them into minor actions. Starting at paragon and depending on the build, characters can have a lot of minor action powers. Also, with those minor actions, characters might swap out their normal weapon/implement for a defensive one (such as a...
  15. Ferghis

    Warden AC Gimped Defender ?

    The warden doesn't have the highest AC (but has a lot of HP and surges), but your AC is a bit low, as was pointed out above. Consider picking up a heavy shield and, if your secondary ability score is less than 18 at level 8, consider asking the DM if you can reapportion some of your ability...
  16. Ferghis

    Immediate Reaction Clarification

    bargle0 is correct. However, some powers are poorly worded, and sometimes (rarely) the clear intent of the power clashes with the rule. I think there is a waist item that lets you roll a save against being dazed as an immediate reaction to becoming dazed. Under RAW, that clearly doesn't work...
  17. Ferghis

    Heroic Threats: A D&D Kickstarter

    This post is here solely to see a preview of the work.
  18. Ferghis

    D&D 4E Desired 4E program?

    OOOH, yes, this! Good call. The initiative tracker I described would be much more work, which would delay availability of the product, so I would rather have Unwise's thing.
Top