Search results

Yeah that's my problem with modern (3e+) DnD- it becomes difficult to run a consistent setting that isn't over the top high fantasy.. but it's a bigger problem (IMO) with 5e because the PCs can punch so far above their weight class even in tier 2, but especially at tier 3 and after. One...

Ha, if you think Tales of the Valiant is bad, don't look into Level Up A5E; I really enjoy a lot of it, but it provides players with WAY more tools and fun bits n bobs- it basically has 3.5e's Tome of Battle built into it; martial maneuvers (all non-casters get them to some degree) can be...

I guess tell them he's not a fighter- he's a warrior! Maybe that's why it was so easy for him to get 15 hit dice :'D

I think they're complaining about the lack of consistency in the book. On the other hand, I guess it shows that they're made by different designers, or they have different themes in which some adventures alignment may be a feature, and others it may not. Or it's just random and inconsistent, I'm...

How does that factor in when figuring the party's side of things? They have a CR 3 sidekick, for example. Does it count as a level 6 PC in the party?

Can you elaborate on that? Yeah it's a toughie when it's baked into the system like that. How do you fight it? Any examples? I very much appreciate your insights on the matter!

I see where you're coming from, but that's assuming that PCs and NPCs are built with the same rules again- which they are not. And we touch on the "levels aren't a real thing in the world... but would I know that that gladiator is more powerful than that veteran? What separates them? What about...

I'm surprised that it's the gladiator that stood out.. it's basically the same as the 5e14 gladiator- it saw almost no changes to 5e24. The thug NPC statblock became pretty infamous at our tables. CR 1/2, 30hp, 2 attacks, pack tactics. But really, they have 5 hit dice. If we called them...

Not to mention that they lack a lot of the features that a PC has. Maybe they have one neat trick, a PC has half a dozen.

Older editions' descriptions of Hold Person are starting to look more and more attractive. 2e, for example:

I'm going to assume "campaign framework" could also be called "campaign outline." High-view bulletpoints and suggestions of 3 eberron campaign ideas. "In chapter 3 of The Chimes of Midnight campaign, the big threat is the Villainous Enclave mentioned in chapter 2- they take control of a...

Yeah, but there's only a certain amount of rules overhead that I can handle... I gave the example in the OP of making a ruling "you CAN wear it on your belt, but if you get critted then you make a save vs getting set on fire by your lamp oil..." but who has to remember that if it's to be...

Yup, though I think plenty of folk appreciate both ideas, not just simulationist OR gameist. For me it's a gameist thing, but I appreciate having the simulationist reasonings.

I'm surprised that you're making this a project for yourself.. it seems like a perfect instance for player creativity! But to answer your question... yeah, a drago-skeleto-mobile.

Care to share?

Does it happen often? No. I don't encourage it, the players tend to avoid doing it themselves. When it DOES happen, I'm sort of forced to up my energy and bounce between both groups to keep them engaged... and you can be sure that if one group gets into a combat, the other is going to as well...

Honestly the biggest surprise to me here is that someone is basing their investments off of DnD's performance, with regards to Hasbro's value. WotC is its lions' share of value, yeah, but MtG is what makes WotC's money. I'm sure hoping to get more value out of the DnD brand is a factor, but...

IIRC @mearls said that he (they? I'm sure it was a few people that made the case) had to make a strong case that there should be a 5th edition of DnD. I forget where he said as such, I'd have liked to have seen the ?presentation? they'd made for it :D

In my mind, "old" comfortably sits in the 80s and earlier. When we get to the 90s, yes at this point it's older media 'cuz it's 2025, but I guess it wasn't old to me. Farscape came out in the late 90s but I'd grapple with calling it old.