Search results

There is a simplicity in playing this way. Yet, I feel that this is the beginning of unmooring of role playing from the game. How much are players making decisions based on the imagined perceptions of their characters, and how much are they finding optimal choices in rules-space. Continuing...

The were tiger is stated as neutral, with slightly below average int and above average wisdom. Unless an unusual specimen, I would expect the weretiger to be neither greedy nor untrustworthy, but not especially loyal, either. You’ll need to work out a motivation and a personality for him. Why...

Re: Targetting. What happens if, in a dimly lit area, a Fireball is shot at a location which is in a mirror? Note the differences between the 1e and 5e spell descriptions! TomB

Is it that a spectral weapon cannot be attacked, or that attacks against one won’t do anything? Certainly, an arrow could be shot at one. Backing up a little, would a wall of force block the movement of a spiritual weapon? I can accept that the visible manifestation is akin to the dot from a...

Reading the 5e description of spiritual weapon, nothing says that it cannot be attacked or grabbed. However, it has no hit points, harness, or AC, and is described as being spectral. Ghost touch, or the equivalent would be necessary to interact with it. I’d say that it takes on a physical...

None of my cats ever had a clue. I’m pretty sure laser pointers strongly trigger a house cat‘s vision and motion detection — in an almost hard-wired way. TomB

Morris, I’m sorry to hear. I hope your illness does not worsen and that your recovery is quick. Tom Bitonti

Whoops, wrong thread. Transferring to the correct one. TomB

Well, I’m ok with their non-phone uses. The current iPhone cameras are great. I just wish they were better phones. The ergonomics are terrible and the speaker and microphone placement are lousy. And the volume upper limit is quite low. And the phone UI can use improvements. And call...

I’ve always found iphones to be decent devices … except they are terrible phones. TomB

Does this suffer from the bag o’ rats trick with cleave and attacks of opportunity from 3e? it seems to be easily convertible to an attack spell by a similar mechanic. Let out a bag of mostly harmless but angry critters and leach advantage from their attacks to power high level effects which...

Holy thread necromancy, Batman! TomB

I don’t care about labels on music or video games. In either case, I’ll get any warning that I need from reviews. I would appreciate a lot more warnings for movies and shows that have excessive violence or sexual content, especially if that content is gratuitous or simple “ugly”. I find that...

In which case, say that in the prefix. If the point of the entire book is to present the folklore in it's historical form, explain that, and include in the explanation a statement that the historical form includes a level of detail not typically present. Tell people the value of including the...

The Glashtyn: A text consistency problem: Are the preferred targets “young beautiful”. “young lonely”, or simply “young” women? Each descriptions suggests different motivations: Targeting beauty because of jealousy. Targeting the lonely suggests an opportunistic but cowardly predator. The...

While (I presume) historically accurate, the gender specificity could be removed without destroying the essential creature. Then you could add a sidebar that provides a historical note. I think that would remove most of the problems with this writeup, while still providing historical accuracy...

So … we should be careful about a terminology shift to “malevolent“. That means “having or showing a wish to do evil to others”. As we are (essentially) having a discussion of the meaning of “evil”, we can’t use “malevolent“ as having a definite meaning. TomB

Not everyone agrees (or agreed) with this. Hence, arguments over whether using summon monster to summon evil monsters was an evil act. TomB

The thing about tags … in 3.5, there was (mostly) the sense that they had not just their defined interactions ( cold does double damage against vulnerable to cold) but also that they were descriptive (cold means the spell actually was cold). I say mostly, because not rarely people also had a...

Not everyone was killed. At least (the remaining “true”) good clerics were whisked away to safety. And the society wasn’t good anymore. It had been taken over by hubris, and had other problems. The high priest‘s ultimate sin was to make demands to their god. TomB