Search results

Come and get it has a special place of shame: The problem was not the power structure. The problem was that any reasonable interpretation pushed you into problems. In 3E, a similar ability would either be a telepathic compulsion, which ought not to affect mindless creatures, and should be...

I’m finding the damage on a miss discussion amusing, in that, if we accept that hit points represent such things as exhaustion, morale, and luck, then both the attacker and defender should potentially gain or lose hit points on any attack. After all, ought not a successful attack improve the...

Undead are evil (1): In many systems, undead have a drive similar to or worse than a starving pit bull. Deliberately creating such a creature is wrong (evil). Using such creatures with at best tenuous control over them is similarly wrong (evil). That undead act as starving pit bulls seems...

I can (kindof) justify this because an attack of the wrong damage type will be less likely to take out an opponent. Continuing with the example of the 8 hit point target, with swords doing 4 (or 1-7) points of damage. If the target has DR 5/Silver, then most attacks with a sword have a much...

I entirely agree. The view of hit points that I presented is hard to align with events which should be directly damaging. For example, there is little that can be done to avoid damage from a fall. Then, a more realistic way of handling fall damage might be to represent it as a coup-de-grace...

Apologies up front for the mathy-ness of this note. In my view, hit points aren't trying to directly simulate anything. Hit points do relate to all manner of character state, for example, Health, Vigor, and Divine Favor. The relationship, however, is indirect: Hit points are intended to...

Part of the Pathfinder schedule is a subscription service of modules and adventure path volumes. That neatly fills the void left when Dungeon went out of print. (Don't get me started whining about the online Dungeon replacement!). I am a long time Pathfinder subscriber. How does Pathfinder...

Going back to the very first post: I'm highly suspicious of statistics that are provided with less than a very very careful analysis. Most of what I get from this is that 4E sold less than 3E, and was expected to do better. This gives a basis to ask two questions: (1) Why did 4E sell less...

Damage on a miss seems more palatable when there there is a resource other than hit points which was expended that made the attack miss. Most commonly, deflection (shield block or parry) or dodge. Say, if one could have an extra reaction at a cost of stamina points. If hit points include such...

Well, except that hp are rather a poor mechanism for anything like exhaustion, the accumulation of small wounds, morale, or divine favor. They strip away all of the flavor of that, so much that I wonder if that consideration was anything but a poor attempt to rationalize them, added after their...

The nature of hit points seems similar to the treatment given to electrons: in one view, they are a continuously variable flow, in another, they are individual particles. A character receiving a strike perhaps can receive a similar strike ten times, successfully dodging or deflecting the...

I’m still dissatisfied by the lack of scaling to the amount of damage. Concentration DCs scale with damage. I’d be happier if the damage caused a new death save, not an automatic failure. Perhaps adding the damage to the DC. TomB

Well, at this layer of rules, a hit is a probabilistic grouping of damage, from potentially one or multiple sources. Then, the effect should be equally probabilistic. A more consistent rule would be that each “hit“ causes a new death save, adding the damage to the DC. To me, the problem is...

Which addresses the second point, but not the first: Even as actual damage, is there one strike, or potentially several? TomB

So … a problem with the base rule is that it is inconsistent with the meaning of attacks in general. A successful weapon attack is not necessarily a single successful strike. (A single successful attack may not even be physical damage.) If individual strikes from weapons are not counted, why...

Eh, anyone else just think the three failed saves rule is itself the problem? Or, that the saves caused by damage don’t care about the amount of damage? Three one point hits have the same effect as three d8 hits. I know this gets us out of rules interpretations. Also, it gets away from the...

My sense of it is that the Loom is a fail-safe for he who remains, not for the TVA. The understanding of what the Loom was for was wrong, until Loki goes back to He Who Remains. Loki decides to not try to preserve the timelines. He breaks the Loom, almost killing both the Sacred Timeline as...

In 5E, with bounded accuracy, that is largely the case. But bounded accuracy is a relatively new idea. Another principle is that the environment should scale with the player. A "locked door" is expected to be a "more well locked door" at 10'th level than at 5'th level. This was more...

Sure. But it still feels like an an odd encounter which was added into a crypt crawl, without doing much to integrate the encounter with the dungeon. A dungeon to which a hydra encounter was added, vs, a dungeon which has a hydra which may be encountered. What is the story reason (or dungeon...

Well, you might have a chat with the water weird (or maybe not). Or drag a cow down into the dungeon. Or try to sneak by. Or wait for the hydra to sleep, or for it to be away. The golden idol was protected by a gauntlet, which is usually linear. Sometimes, linear makes sense. Proving a...