Search results

  1. Odhanan

    Edition Fatigue

    And that might actually kill interest in the game altogether.
  2. Odhanan

    Edition Fatigue

    "Must spread XPs..." This thread is spot on. Well done, Korgoth. I'm going to surprise some people, but, although I would like for another iteration of the game to become a true long-lasting game classic, I would accept this compromise, and I think this is what actually should happen to the...
  3. Odhanan

    Is it time for 5E?

    I think you should be thinking about taking it on the road or something. You're one hilarious guy! :lol:
  4. Odhanan

    The Role of the Wizard, or "How Come Billy Gets to Create a Demiplane?"

    It's actually Gary Gygax that made me realize this while talking about this on two different occasions, where he told me something to the effect of "the story's the stuff you talk about after the game's done." I can't find the quotes back for the life of me, but there it is. Take that as you will.
  5. Odhanan

    The Role of the Wizard, or "How Come Billy Gets to Create a Demiplane?"

    I chose deliberately to leave that part of the conversation alone, because I do not believe there is such a thing as a "narrative" in a role playing game, nor should there be. To put it simply, RPGs do not tell "stories." You're welcome to believe they do. I'm just reacting to the factually...
  6. Odhanan

    The Role of the Wizard, or "How Come Billy Gets to Create a Demiplane?"

    Because you're a magic user, and if you can indeed have retinues, they will be of a different nature (notice for instance the Followers for Upper Level Characters in the First Ed DMG p. 16-17, which does not list magic users). If you're trying to act like you are a mercenary leader as a wizard...
  7. Odhanan

    The Role of the Wizard, or "How Come Billy Gets to Create a Demiplane?"

    You know, no matter how "well designed" (whatever that means) a car, a bad driver will remain a bad driver, and drive it sooner or later into a ditch, a wall, off a cliff or whatnot. No matter what kind of car you choose, being a decent driver is a requirement to handling it properly. It's not...
  8. Odhanan

    The Role of the Wizard, or "How Come Billy Gets to Create a Demiplane?"

    This "account" is so factually untrue and biased it is kind of mind-boggling to read, honestly. The fundamental difference between the fighter and the magic user is that one class has some abilities that are strictly scripted by the rules to limit their scope precisely, aka Spells, whereas the...
  9. Odhanan

    Why gronard?

    Did you just call me a Gros Connard?! :confused: :lol: ;)
  10. Odhanan

    I'm considering dropping Pathfinder to return to D&D 2e.

    Dude, I just got one thing to say to you: get back to the game you really like, play the hell out of it, and have the time of your life. Life's too short to play games you don't really like. ;)
  11. Odhanan

    [WotC's recent insanity] I think I've Figured It Out

    I don't need WotC, and I don't have the intention to write a fantasy game of my own. I am just content to run First Edition AD&D. Don't get me wrong: I appreciate what they did with Gamma World and intend to run it. But I really do not need WotC at this point to catter to my D&D needs. At all.
  12. Odhanan

    Is D&D (WotC) flaming out?

    Absolutely wrong.
  13. Odhanan

    Let's say D&D ceases to exist...what do you play?

    The first game coming to mind is Call of Cthulhu. Then, Stormbringer, Hawkmoon, RuneQuest, Nephilim 2e, Bloodlust, the World of Darkness games, Dark Heresy, Rogue Trader, Deathwatch, Warhammer 1e, Gamma World, WEG Star Wars, In Nomine Satanis/Magna Veritas... Then, oh so many of them!
  14. Odhanan

    Why I don't GM by the nose

    Tell that to your players. Really. Communication is key. Communicate your expectations to your players, and listen to theirs. If communication is effective, then you'll find the sweet spot that satisfies everyone by trial and error. If you just wait for them to do stuff and complain after the...
  15. Odhanan

    Fake TPKO ("It was only a dream")

    My advice: don't do it. It is, frankly, a very bad idea.
  16. Odhanan

    Gamma World Cards and Alternate Uses

    I just posted on the Gamma Whirl blog about the GW cards, their basic default use, and suggested various ways for GMs to use them alternately. You can check out the entry by clicking here if you want. Since this is the subject of lots of conversations on various message boards, I thought I...
  17. Odhanan

    Tabletopocalypse Now - GMS' thoughts about the decline in the hobby

    Battle Chess? Here you go! :D
  18. Odhanan

    D&D Starter Set

    The Dungeons & Dragons Fantasy Role Playing Game Starter Set, or “new Red Box”, as it has come to be called, is an introductory boxed set to the D&D 4th edition role playing game, published by Wizards of the Coast, Inc. This product is available in most, if not all, local gaming stores, along...
Top