Search results

  1. Odhanan

    D&D 4E 4E Dislike - a hypothesis

    This is a very good post. I believe Dausuul is on to something here. (must spread XP and all that)
  2. Odhanan

    D&D 4E 4E Dislike - a hypothesis

    I started playing with AD&D and loved it. I ran games with Mentzer and loved it. 2nd edition unfolded and I liked some stuff about it, but quickly was drawn away playing and running a multitude of other games. I burnt out on gaming around 1999, and came back to D&D with 3rd ed. I loved 3rd ed...
  3. Odhanan

    The Praemal Tales Revived

    Hi there, guys! I just reactivated the Praemal Tales blog and want to get the word out. If you have any comment, question or feedback, please don't hesitate. Here's the piece of news I'm posting around: Follow the adventures of an all-female, rune-bearing adventuring group as they explore the...
  4. Odhanan

    Essentials doing what it was supposed to do?

    I was not fine with Daily powers for fighters. I am an experienced D&D player, but I also ran a Paris by Night Chronicle for close to 10 years, and still run a New World of Darkness reboot of that Chronicle. I don't think my problems with dailies had anything to do with a lack of experience with...
  5. Odhanan

    Essentials doing what it was supposed to do?

    Well, I did start re-examining 4e rules slightly before Essentials' release, but as far as I am concerned, it does its intended job in that it makes me want to run the game, where I would not have run the game after reading the original 4e books. So I guess it's working for me.
  6. Odhanan

    Gamma World is a Gas!

    I can't wait to receive it myself. This is going to be a blast. :)
  7. Odhanan

    Hammerfast, population 12,000! what?

    Just verisimilitude and fact checking missing is all.
  8. Odhanan

    How to do a doomed, "Halo Reach" type game?

    *stops after reading the first few words* ARGH NO! No spoilers! I haven't received the game yet! :D
  9. Odhanan

    The most important question of all

    Since the New Red Box truly is the heir of Holmes D&D, 5e will therefore be Mentzer D&D reborn, with an Advanced D&D version published later on to renew the sales, since Wizards will have pointedly pointed out that "there will be no 5.5". The Cycle will be complete. The world will come to an...
  10. Odhanan

    MERGED - "About Edition Wars" threads x9

    I'd count Pathfinder on the same line as 4E, in the sense that 4E would be 8th edition possibility #1, and Pathfinder 8th edition #2.
  11. Odhanan

    MERGED - "About Edition Wars" threads x9

    OD&D (1974) Holmes D&D -> AD&D First Edition Moldvay Cook D&D Mentzer D&D AD&D 2nd edition D&D 3rd edition D&D 3.5 D&D 4E i.e. Technically Essentials would be the 9th edition of the D&D game. The 10th, if you count the AD&D2 "Player's Options" as a new edition, which I wouldn't. BUT I...
  12. Odhanan

    Blood Moon Rising (Labyrinth Lord)

    Blood Moon Rising is an adventure designed by Peter C. Spahn, published by Small Niche Games, for 3 to 6 characters of 1st to 3rd level. It uses Labyrinth Lord (the B/X Moldvay/Cook D&D retro-clone) rules and stats, but is compatible with most old school D&D fantasy game systems. The product...
  13. Odhanan

    Older Editions and "Balance" when compared to 3.5

    It was beyond APL+4, at which point the book specifically advised to rarely use these types of encounters since the death of a PC at the very least was close to unavoidable, and there was a fine line between a challenge and a frustrating encounter, or somesuch. It's from memory, but I'm pretty...
  14. Odhanan

    Older Editions and "Balance" when compared to 3.5

    Sleep an autowin in the Moathouse? :confused: Now, when you reach that kind of silliness, you know it's time to let the point drop. Seriously. ;)
  15. Odhanan

    Is there any way to get a 3rd At-Will, besides...

    Yeah, that could work. Nothing's like good old communication between a player and his DM. :)
  16. Odhanan

    Thread action buttons...

    Too thick. Please crop the height further, from 26 px to about 15-20 px. Thanks. :)
  17. Odhanan

    [merged] Site speed threads x3

    Hey, Morrus. Could you shrink your sig a bit or something? All your posts are deformed, and I have a resolution of 1280x800 on my laptop. That's driving me nuts. Thanks. :D
  18. Odhanan

    The Big Winner of Essentials

    ... or a rock, for that matter. Absolutely! ;)
  19. Odhanan

    Metaplots - it wasn't just TSR that did them

    I don't see how other companies festering their own metaplots somehow excuses the fact that TSR was doing it. But here's my point: I think that TSR is particularly blamed for this because of D&D, and how metaplots clash against the old-school sandbox, the open alternate universe, and the notion...
  20. Odhanan

    "Essentials Only" possible in CB?

    Well, it's the point.
Top