Search results

It was already mentioned by @CleverNickName but I'm going to take it a step further on why these aren't just white boarding problems because most on my 5e games have gone into the low to mid teens. That might put me outside the average, but it very much runs 5e through the acid test and exposed...

Why does an opinion on if combat is tedious or not need a comparison? Quite a few posts through the thread have detailed or quibbled over reasons why individual posters feel one way or the other if you were looking for more than yes or no.

Thats quite the selective quote to stop just before a word like and with a sentence directly addressing fiduciary responsibility. Are you claiming that "making a slightly changed half-edition is the only way to accomplish that goal"? Alternately should we assume that your choice to stop the...

So do I, but I took part in attempting to correct incredibly bad assumptions that often reacted as if we were talking about binary compatibility for compiled code. I also recall being dogpiled by a small and very vocal echo chamber reinforcing that had assumption and wotc making very little (if...

A significant chunk of what you call a "majority"∆ will enthusiastically support anything wotc publishes. Bad polling and the sort of questionable testing that allowed so many millions to b involved in sigil thinking a vtts was a video game ∆ we've all heard the phrase "lies damned lies and...

To be fair, plenty of them expressed concerns about the obvious power creep with PCs during the "playtest" too. Sometimes they are still running or playing 5e often enough to be annoyed by a design ethos that seems to be guided by little more than "19 out of 20 toddlers polled wanted more...

It's easier to tone police him or the video than it is to provide a positive defense for toxic player behavior or explain why we should always just declare the gm to be unreasonable until proven otherwise by an impossible standard. Heck, by not transcribing the video it became more difficult...

In some ways I think that it goes even further than bureaucracy when it comes to Romans. They also built economies to serve the empire's needs. Most of us probably came across the factoid about them often paying soldiers with salt. What you don't normally see is details about how that salt...

I'd add C: one other person else will, but it's only an option through technicality because they are not at all good at it. That goes back to the perma GM who is stuck or they ultimately walks on a group of friends. The last group I walked from that person was one of two wall flowers who would...

I wouldn't say "only" or "can". Often it's more relationship a friend group or whatever. Although 5e really did a lot that either brought in people who approach the game with fairly toxic mindset when it comes to who is responsible for everyone's fun§ or encouraged them to adopt that toxic...

I think that it was a great video that made good points about all three points. The dog piling of people who complain about things in 5e that annoy them, the groups who view their GM like a servant, & the lsn party analogy for players who don't care about if anyone else at the table is having...

On the subject of fixing mud, it's incredibly difficult on any meaningful scale without elevation of terrain or digging significant drainage ditches. It takes quite a bit to freeze water and those water absorbing crystals you can buy to mix into plant soil were originally developed (or improved...

The spellcasting provokes an AoO thing should never have been removed just as the clearly defined and present on the character sheet body slots being turned into the same quantum clown show of armpits multiple quivers/backpacks/etc and such was a mistake. The quantum hand slot that 5e bends...

No. That was never the use case that it was designed for . It's use case was to provide features that excite individuals who wouldn't be using it

Not my point. When talking about locking down the quantum "hand slot" of her 5e creates... carving a loophole by holding your weapon in your armpit in order to free the hand holding it for spellcasting is such a slapstick move rooted in some form of loophole seeking tedious malicious compliance...

Going to add one i don't think was mentioned but not sure if it's cantrip or first level spell. Endure elements would change the course of history and probably be something almost everyone learns in childhood. I forget the name , but I read a book a few years ago where the mc kicked off a lot...

This "armpit" maneuver feels like an invitation to be automatically and reflexively disarmed like you sometimes saw Jackie Chan do in his more comedy focused movies. Wrt the move to shield hand, there used to be a type of shield that was designed for that sort of mechanical niche but the...

While true about pre3.x, I think that to some degree you are substituting "can't be bothered to learn the rules or read/skim the chargen stuff" for being unable to make a PC in 5e without ddb because you are no "mathemagician". I don't think that chargen even enters into adding double digit...

Did you switch from d&d to talking about something like DCC or shadowdark? What edition did you start with that you are claiming has easier chargen than 5e?

Im not sure if it was raised as an option example but the 1600s siege on the Dutch East India trading company 's fort provincia &fort zeelandia(semi interlinked rolling siege).it makes a great example because it has such detailed records and they sprawl from a sneak water attack at high tide on...