Search results

There was a bit of discussion & high level generalities about the rules for social/"negotiation" stuff earlier that skirted around getting too deep in specifics earlier in this (and the earlier) thread so I wanted to share this since I came across an SRD kinda equivalent that has them :D...

I have run games where one of the players was the host and it worked ok. That even made it easy for him to have us come check on his place when he took a work trip since he had someone he considered trustworthy enough to have a key. That game started at a nearby FLGS and he suggested the move...

Yea I was thinking more about the well trod metagaming social structure where the player with a job in sales or something gets to "roleplay" around the mechanics while the GM is expected to just kinda let them keep spinning the interaction. Having those mechanics when I ran it during some of...

Haven't finished reading the new PDF yet but Iirc NPCs also have a value for how patient they are. If you need to ask it counts against that

I ran some of the earlier packets at a nearby FLGS and we had a blast. Haven't had time to skim or read through the two books/PDFs that came out the other day but looking forward to making some time & saw this Also enjoyed listening to this at the gym this morning 😀

Since they came up... I think that the `gameplay benefits of those 3.5 ~750gp ~50 charge CLW wands were far superior to 5e's mundane 50gp trivially available healing potions sandwiched between the rations water skins & torches. Those wands offered both opportunity cost for wasteful use &...

I don't think so but maybe for different reasons than the ones Umbran mentioned. Most of the 5e campaigns I played or ran tended to fall into the 12-18 month range unless they were doomed groups that couldn't stick together in a shared hobby more than a couple sessions. The old surveys (afaik)...

Most of my games run into low to mid teens but I have very little doubt about that 7th level stat being reasonably accurate based on that experience. Level 7 is late in tier 2 of play, that's where the excess of over insulating tier1 of play without usefully supporting the kinds of gm stress...

I tried many things to make healing potions interesting treasure in 5e and could never fix the two pronged core of the problem in a way that brought back the "ok awesome, who should get that" vibes of base & greater healing potions in the past without descending into an adversarial quagmire. The...

I think that it's a more fundamental problem due to players entering the hobby in a way that encourages them to view any changes from the GM as some kind of BadWrongFun EvilKillerGM thing. going beyond the small example encouraging the GM that @James Gasik embedded a couple posts back, the...

There is no need to make derrogitory claims about the skill of GM's who make their own adventures or modify monsters to justify unreasonable player expectations like this to support the gospel of Run As Written OR ELSE. Even Wotc's own :rolleyes:"greatly written modules":rolleyes: have been...

Dfrpg is 100% Urban fantasy too. It's literally based on an urban fantasy book series and tounge in cheek is written to look like the characters from it made a ttrpg about their world

Agreed Yes they did AND they gave a bunch of examples that mostly point to base levelup5e core rules that differ from wotc dnd5e. The exception was really the GM saying no to a fear they consider to be problematic I would expect those differences to be highlighted by the gm whenever they...

Im still skeptical since I faced similar claims from players who didn't even take the time to read their own class's section. "I just can't keep up with all the rules that keep changing" when those "changes" were in the book for anyone to read and only became relevant when they came up during...

I made a post yesterday about them. More than one of the "house rules" he described plausibly appear likely to be base rules within level up. If I had a player who asked me to list evertrukes change between base wotc dnd5e and base levelup5e. I can't imagine being all that willing to go beyond...

When I was running levelup for players new to it I would frequently need to stop & explain rules that were different from wotc's dnd5e to players who I'm skeptical even skimmed the book. While levelup doesn't have "lingering injuries", you very much appear to be describing the fatigue & strife...

How exactly would a GM running an adventure they themselves out together do that any more strictly than running what they wrote? Also read the tail end of the post you quoted "now I think the way AL chains GMs in the ALDMG with what amounts to THOUMUSTHALLRUNMODULEANDRULESABSOLUTEASWRITTEN...

Your just showing why you quit reading the table halfway through and discarded the rest in favor of hyper focusing on only half of it. Checking the table for a given check was not at all for those of us who actually played tend understood it, there were even sections in the phb like the one...