Search results

Oh, i think I saw a sentence about a tavern tale, but didn't latch on to it. But that could indeed put the entire game in a new perspective, if you decide to think of it as a multiplayer adventure of Munchausen :D Complete over the top descriptions of ability effects and shrugging off even the...

I think a major challenge is when we encounter situations where the rules themselves can be described as "unfair". Then we get into a double bind - be unfair by following the unfair rules, or be unfair by not consistently following the rules? Traditional play tend to opt for the latter. This...

I read this into the second point, given the parenthesis. The DM wanting to please the players seem to fit into the formulation. You could argue that way of putting it makes it not sound so charitable, but that is rhetoric I guess..

Don't need a full reset. You could do what would would have done to tweak the situation anyway. My examples was that even extreme measures might be open with the honest approach :) For instance: "I realise now this monster has too many HP so it will become a slog. Do you mind if I halve...

The real value of stoping the world when you are making adjustments is that if you make a habit out of that, the players will recognise that when you are not stopping the world, things are actually going the way the dice tells. That can do wonders in terms of tension and the feeling of...

I have a radical suggestion for that situation: Speak up! Point out that you messed up royal, you now realise that this encounter stinks, and ask if it is ok for the players that you retroactively fix up some stuff so you can actually get to have some fun. My guess is that most players would...

Ok, fine. When I have used the words "feel" and "feeling" here, I have been referring exclusively what it appear you recognice as "visceral response". It didn't occur to me that the word could have any wider meaning in the sense you here present. So with that clarification in place, are we...

How would you describe "the feeling of having had a victory that wasn't actually deserved, but you fully believe was deserved"? I have a hard time seeing how this feeling would be different from "the feeling of a deserved victory"? As such, I have been using the latter, shorter form to describe...

I would think the world would have been a much better place, if it hadn't been possible to have false beliefs...?

As a side note. I find this part a bit funny. This was an official WotC adventure. Hope someone over there are taking notes :D

I think we are agreeing in all the premises and the conclusion. I think the only thing that seperates us might be this one sentence. I acknowledged the core you seem to put into it in my first post in this exchange: However even if the feeling is based on a deception, the feeling is felt...

Both of these were very experienced players and had calculated that they had a solid chance of taking the hit under normal circumstances. Both were aghast when I didn't overrule the crit that took them out. The point in context is that characters ending up in situations that are more dangerous...

I have twice had players actively putting themselves in front of a charging boss while low on HP. Situations where characters can survive a hit, but not a crit is not that rare in D&D pre 5ed. 5ed sort of fixes this, which I now realise sort of invalidates my example - though I have witnessed...

The context of my post was that @EzekielRaiden claimed "I'm very much of the opinion that there is nothing you can achieve using fudging, that you cannot also achieve without using it." I assume you agree that the feeling of triumph at a cost is different from the feeling of a triumph without...

Nope. Big boss fight - the action is a big known slam that the players fear. The boss is down on 4 HP. You decided to not do a HP fudge no last hit, as you assessed the players could sweat little bit more to really earn the victory (and the last attack also was a relatively low roll boring...

Evidence produced:

Ok, now I am curious! Classic scenario: Battle is almost over, but characters are low on resources. Behind the screen the enemy's last desperate attack shows a crit. You know honoring it will kill a character. You know fudging it to a hit will bring the character to unconscious, and the players...

Actively being updated after release at least. Have not checked out the state yet, planned on waiting for new proper system release

I think you can theme it with something like these army people being drilled in how to avoid the blast zone. It is not like it is a major explosion anyway, and likely focused inwards. Any kind of monster can be tedious if meeting too many of them, but force move finishes might not be the only...

Just read the slamming rules on forced movement. Those are absolutely insane! I think I have never been so happy and excited reading any rules in my life :D