Search results

I would not pay the 500 golds to play them, but I can state DnD minis, skirmish game, Confrontation, miniature battle.

Would you still create a character with no magic/only magic? Yes, they feel interchangeable. You describe pretty much 4ed, where being Martial or arcane don’t matter much. Would you learn a specialist spell for your specialist, e.g. a thief that can unlock with magic? Yes, for sure. I want to...

The definition of super hero may vary, but Netflix One piece is doing very well. super hero surely need a super writer behind the screen to survive!

Team sure. The game assume collaboration between players, but also with the DM. Sport? Competitive play is more a choice of play style.

Indeed looking at the UA playtest, some players will be unsatisfied for another 10 years. But 5ed can be house ruled! So some spells can still be banned, put at a higher level, or even rewrite. There are not that much spells, a dozens or so. The OP even bring another simple solution, tweak...

There is a section in the DMG Know your players, that can give hints on how to engage your players: Acting Exploring Instigating Fighting Optimizing Problem solving Story telling Real life team work concept can be used too. that can help to understand a team of players dynamic. Honey's Five...

It makes an hilarious moment. This character is coward, self sufficient, but I manage to make him play with the team. The discipline of the party is at the level of the Guardians of the Galaxy!

I play PCs with more and more flaws. Recently my wizard use his action during a fight to light up a cigar, claiming that he has seen enough action, and he would wait in the back for a while.

The wonder is that 5ed and level Up and even 5.5 are still compatible despite they are aiming different audience.

That is a spartan way to play dnd 5e. But there is quite enough material on the Web to avoid buying any material from Wotc. Wotc provide new idea, controversy, some interesting rules, but it is still possible to play in a close bubble for years. Some friend on mine play 4ed until last year...

In reality, you buy the Phb, mm, and DM guide in 2014, and you buy back the new phb in 2024. that is the minimum link you can handle with Wotc.

3 rounds of fight per rest, PCs are overpaid!

The Bastion system presented is a flavorful way to handle rewards to PCs. it may help rookie DM to manage downtime, but a DM will soon reach the limits of such system. There will be unbalance in bastion benefits, players will ask to new features, and finally DM will house rule, tweak and adapt...

We can build a martial system that will be much more complex than actual spells and spell slots management. It should not be hard to make fighter turn twice as long as wizard turn because the player will have so many things to manage and evaluate. Defensive stance, bait, feint, management of...

I think bastion should not add mechanical features to PCs. We have enough with classes, MC, feats and magic item.

if you need an excel grid to explain or manage Bastion rules it´s a no go for me!

A UA on spells.

My favorite option is not there. Dont allow spell over 2th level for PCs.

Keep actual ones from 5ed. They do the job.

It’s a nice idea to add flavor to a game. it will be fine, until the the release of the first guide who will rate all « must have bastion » at each level to optimize characters!