Search results

In the end I banned Silvery Barbs. Those who know what this does will know the reason, even if you don't agree with me. I may have missed previous discussions on this topic in this thread. My problem with Shield is that it is most useful for classes that already wear armor. If you have a good...

Late to the party and I have only read the first and last page. Some general reflections. My group isn't very fond of logistics, and we don't really focus on this side of the game, ever. No counting of arrows or rations. In 5E I've had great success with LevelUp's exploration rules. I bought...

About Savage Tide and Paizo adventure paths in general, the early adventures are usually the best. Second Darkness has already been mentioned, i used that as an ingress to Curse of the Crimson Throne and the Golden Goblin was the PCs base for much of the campaign. To link with another thread...

On a tangent, this makes me want to make a Blades in the Dark hack about ruling kingdoms. I admit I am am currently infatuated with BitD. :) Completely agree. In the computer game there are mods to remove the time-frame limits, which I used. In the TTRPG I GMed i ditched the kingdom management...

The computer game from Owlcat Games really improved this aspect of the story. The villain presents herself early on and keeps up just the kind of annoying monologue that makes you hate her. She does this in dreams, making her invulnerable and makes you the player unable to charge to your death...

I find it hard to get the players to actually read and absorb the Players' Guides. And after the first scenario everyone was hyped for adventures in the cool city of Sasserine. I had warned everyone this was becoming a naval campaign, but if I recall, the planar episodes had not yet been...

Thanks for the warning. Like the power rules earlier, this is not something I am going to do soon - quite a bit of work before that, and I don't master the regular downtime rules yet.

I suspect the main reason late bosses don't even make cameo appearances repeatedly in a campaign is that the designer is afraid the PCs will charge the villain and either prematurely kill them or all die themselves.

Except for Jade Regent, that I didn't play, all these examples are how it worked out in actual play.

Continuing to delve into BitD. We gave up our trial run of Candela Obscura and are now on Princess World - Frontier Kingdoms session 2. But that's not what I am going to talk about. I had an idea for something I found hard to do in any other game that might work in BitD, and that is doing a...

Candlekeep is discussed a lot earlier in the thread, and since I am currently playing it, I want to chime in. My campaign is a combination of Kobold Press' Old Margreve (a series of unconnected adventures in the forest of Old Margreve) and Candlekeep Mysteries. And both me and my player have...

I see a lot of this, its the style most popular around here. I personally often GM bought adventures. But adventure paths often does not support their own story, or at least does not advertise themselves enough, making it hard to make suitable characters. My main experience is with Paizo...

In my experience, if the DM focuses on keeping the PCs poor, this is the result. "Why should we help people who only seem to be out to rob us". The problem is that the opposite, too much wealth, is also destructive, making players either want to buy themselves magic items or, if unavailable...

Looking at it now. Its not as wide-ranging as my power options, which I should maybe read to say that I am too wide-ranging. :) At a minimum it something to compare to.

Yay! Thanks for commenting! And now, of course, I am gonna argue. :) I'm all for the flashback and work as a team rules, that's a big part of why I am looking at BitD. That, faster pacing, and less prep work which allows greater player freedom as its easier for the GM to improvise. What I am...

No comments are good comments?

Answering a decade-old post, but I can't find any submission info on Patreon.

I'm feeling really presumptuous now, working outside my experience. I've only played a few sessions of BitD, but I am considering it for my Greyhawk campaign as it moves into the baroque. My players are used to games like DnD where spells/powers play a very important feature, and I am...

Very much agree with this. I'd call this the squick principle - even if you personally hate it you should be able to see that it need not be objectively bad.

I wasn't claiming you did :) I saw sort of defending myself and pointing out this was not my position either. We can set up games where these themes are handled, but that would then be the theme of the game and most certainly something to talk about at session zero.