Search results

  1. Umbran

    I don't get the arguments for bioessentialism

    In theory, perhaps. But, changing the name of the chapter from "races" to "species" doesn't do that in and of itself. You'd have to redesign those species, to actually be different. I don't see many fruit flies in the PHB. Sorry, as above, that's what we'd call "filing the serial numbers...
  2. Umbran

    I don't get the arguments for bioessentialism

    That's an excellent question. I think the answer is that we don't actually need them most of the time. It is perhaps key to remember that the work of fiction that has most influenced our game's thoughts on "races", The Lord of the Rings, by Tolkien, does not use them as simulation of how...
  3. Umbran

    D&D 5E (2024) Heroes of the Borderlands

    Mod note: In the future, please refrain from personal commentary, jabs or insults. If you cannot show that restraint, we can provide restraint for you, but you are unlikely to be happy with it.
  4. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    It isn't the answer... FOR YOU. It's like pineapple on pizza all over again.
  5. Umbran

    Alternatives to map-and-key

    But, it isn't necessarily specifically related to a map. The players need to succeed at 6 actions that would plausibly aid them in achieving their goal, before 3 things go wrong. Going from point A to point B on the map might be a success. But so might putting together a disguise, or getting...
  6. Umbran

    I don't get the arguments for bioessentialism

    I have no idea who feylin or garter folk are, so I cannot speak to them, specifically. But, I can try to address some of the core question here, and I'm going to try to do so without reading the 11 intervening pages that already came up today - so please pardon if I cover ground someone else...
  7. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    Mod note: And I really feel like you are the poster who, after three mod warnings and a couple of threadbans, still figures making it personal is a good idea. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes...
  8. Umbran

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    Mod Note: A couple folks have gotten threadbanned recently... The site owner himself warned people about being constructive... And what comes to your mind is... being snarky? Please do that again if you are bucking to be the next person threadbanned. Everyone: Respectful. Kind...
  9. Umbran

    Purple Dragon Knight Retooled as Banneret in D&D's Heroes of Faerun Book

    Mod Note: And, your own rants against how people posting....? I already warned you before about how you were addressing people, but you continue to attack folks. So, you're done in this discussion. I suggest you not follow this pattern in other discussions either - if you want to attack...
  10. Umbran

    Are Ghosts Real? (a poll)

    No, that's not a problem. We've been dealing with that in quantum mechanics for decades, and do experiments just fine. Which is why you don't start with the conception. You start with the observable phenomenon. It would first look like dropping the assumption that all self-reported...
  11. Umbran

    Judge decides case based on AI-hallucinated case law

    And, more on bad actors.. Subtext: if you are doing crime, don't click the "share" button... https://futurism.com/leaked-chatgpt-lawyer-displace-amazonian
  12. Umbran

    Are Ghosts Real? (a poll)

    That's nonsensical. By that logic, we could not discover new things without knowing what they were beforehand. You do know that you don't generally try to prove negatives, right? There's problems with scope, and non-falsifiablity there.
  13. Umbran

    Are Ghosts Real? (a poll)

    The way to answer "are ghosts real?" Is not to pick thing, call it a ghost, and determine if it is real. The proper process would be to pick a phenomenon, determine if it is real, determine what caused it, and if what caused it is a ghost, then ghosts are real. If you find it was real, and a...
  14. Umbran

    Are Ghosts Real? (a poll)

    Classification comes after study, not before. Allow your investigation to answer the question, rather than prejudice the study with a preconceived notion.
  15. Umbran

    Alternatives to map-and-key

    A timeline is just a map of time, rather than a map of physical space, in which case this reduces to a form of map and key. With respect, it is the norm - the average, usual, or typical way rpgs have been and are currently played. Norms are a matter of statistics, not design philosophy. When...
  16. Umbran

    Are Ghosts Real? (a poll)

    Sure, but that first generation was short. Current estimates are that, in our own galaxy, in the galaxy's habitable zone, there are tens of billions of G-type stars like our sun, with rocky worlds in the star's habitable zone. And, on average, those other stars and their planets are a billion...
  17. Umbran

    D&D General Disparity in PC levels from same party

    Why should we expect players to want their groups to be disparate levels? What is the benefit to them?
  18. Umbran

    SkyNet really is ... here?

    So, to be clear - 1) That isn't what happened in the events spoken of in the video clip. It was a manufactured scenario, not really autonomous or spontaneous action, and no real damage was done in that test. 2) Technically, the computer isn't breaking the law, as it isn't a person. That'd be...
  19. Umbran

    D&D General Disparity in PC levels from same party

    It depends on what kind of game is being run, I suppose. But my initial reaction is that major power differences usually lead to dynamics in play that I find unsatisfying.
  20. Umbran

    Purple Dragon Knight Retooled as Banneret in D&D's Heroes of Faerun Book

    Mod Note: And now you are making the argument personal. There's several reasons one might do this - but none of them are about having a polite and rational discussion about a D&D subclass. So, I'm going to ask you to not make any more pointed personal jabs or attacks, please and thanks.
Top