Search results

Oh, hey, now you're jumping onto the "intentionally breaking the game" line while still holding fast on One True Way. Look, if you're heart is so set on making blatantly fallacious arguments like that, why don't you at least try to make it more subtle? Because I know monster's stats and am...

How about... no. Uh, no. Seriously this is all still out there, so you might want to check before making verifiably false statements. ... What. Seriously, y'all are going One True Way on me? Oh, so now I don't even play D&D? What are you going to say next? That I'm not on a computer? Yeah it...

Well they didn't have temporary IP bans. IP bans and permabans were entirely different. Goldo has been permabanned a lot on WotC, but I don't think he was ever IP'd. The only IP I can think of was some guy who'd go around and post pictures of aborted fetuses everywhere.

No, IP bans were the final step. This was how WotC operated. In fact, I can only think of one IP ban off the top of my head before all of ours.

EDIT: Screw it, responding to such obvious bait is stupid.

Uh, yeah, it kinda is. Maybe not over here, but different places have different policies.

Yep. Shame the real world has absolutely nothing to do with any point I've been making. Except for, you know, all those page's I've quoted. And I find that accusation hilarious coming from the side that refuses to cite anything. I don't think I've ever seen anyone miss the point in quite as...

No, it's closer to you eating a parrot. Face it, an ancient vampire or any other powerful sentient undead is an entirely different creature from a humanoid. It's no different from eating a parrot or an ape(Ignoring, of course, the health problems involved in that). Some, including myself, might...

You haven't looked at the third world lately, have you? Sorry, that sounds nice, but people don't really work like that.

...No, they really don't matter. The soul has left the body, dead stop. Therefore, there is no harm inherent to animating a body. I honestly don't care about people being irrational, all I'm talking about is simple fact. If anyone in the game objects to it on any grounds regarding souls or...

Or they can cast Contact Other Plane and get a completely accurate, unbiased answer to "Is any harm done to the soul of the body if I animate it?" And Wizards are Int-focused, Clerics aren't. I'd side with Wizards in an argument any day of the week. No they aren't. No, they really don't. ...Then...

Including the ones that suggest destroying corpses completely? Or, and here's the big thing, in D&D any such belief is objectively wrong. I'd like stats on that if you don't mind. Only if you redefine "respect" to include things like torching the corpse and being done with it or various other...

The belief structure is completely meaningless. The facts are the facts. Not unless Pelor reaches down and Consecrates/Hallows/Blesses/makes into magic items the corpses of all his followers. I'm not talking about any homebrew. I am talking about the rules. Predatory, sure, but malicious? I'd...

No, they aren't. One is fact, the other isn't. If it's provable that the soul leaves the body, then once it leaves the body then the body is then a meaningless hunk of meat. Necromancy is a completely logical move. In fact, in a setting I was writing, I had what amounted to Skullstone(Without...

Why? Tome of Battle is one of the most well-balanced, best-written, and generally good books written in all of 3.5.

The issue with that argument is that this is knowable. People can and do in any setting with even moderate-leveled casters what happens to a soul upon its death. There's no question. In D&D, any religion who says that the body matters to the soul after death is wrong. Likewise, anyone who undead...

Sure, I'll see and raise you half a dozen example characters who don't qualify for their classes. But, hey, why not? Go ahead. I mean, they'll be nice and Evil again within five minutes of not going on a suicide rush into the Hells. Yes, I know. I do believe I've made my opinions on the...

Read the build before claiming it doesn't work. Wrong. It does exactly what I say it does because that's what it says it does. You really should read the entire build. ...You do know that Domain Wizard is on the SRD. There is no excuse for ignorance like what you're displaying. Different parts...

Monster Manual, page 167: Alignment: Any Evil Page 168: "The process of becoming a lich is unspeakably evil..." Book of Vile Darkness, page 8: "Unliving corpses - corrupt mockeries of life and purity - are inherently evil. Creating them is one of the most heinous crimes against the world that a...

Well, we already new Elan was at minimum level 14, and the casters have been at least level 13 for hundreds of strips(Ignoring, of course, the sudden spike in Durkon's ECL), this isn't exactly surprising, but is at least nice to narrow it down a bit further.