Search results

  1. I

    D&D Movie/TV Here Come The D&D Movie Gaming Tie-Ins!

    That’s a very reasonable hypothesis!
  2. I

    D&D Movie/TV Here Come The D&D Movie Gaming Tie-Ins!

    It boggles my mind to think that there may be no tie-in product with actual RPG content based on the film—no adventure, no starter set, nothing. I figured most likely WotC would produce a combo sourcebook/adventure with movie tie-in stuff like descriptions of the various locations, stat blocks...
  3. I

    D&D General WotC Reveals New Information and Covers for 'Keys from the Golden Vault'

    I like the alt cover and bet it will look great IRL. But apparently this isn't a movie tie-in book after all, at least not directly. That surprises me.
  4. I

    Will WotC release Keys from the Golden Vault with zero promotion due to OGL firestorm?

    This is definitely a movie tie-in book. Its press push may have been postponed due to the OGL fiasco, or it may always have been planned to begin a little later than usual due to the movie promotion timetable (especially after the movie itself was pushed back until late March).
  5. I

    Was the leaked OGL actually a draft?

    How sure are we that the leaked document was meant to be signed? The statement released yesterday is widely seen as including at least one lie: the claim that the leaked document was a “draft.” Most of the commentary I’ve come across insists that this was an executable document intended to be...
  6. I

    D&D General Is D&D Survey Feedback Read? [UPDATED!]

    Funny you should mention Mike Mearls—the man broke a three-and-a-half-year Twitter silence yesterday to retweet two of the tweets denying the “feedback isn’t read” rumor.
  7. I

    WotC Talks OGL... Again! Draft Coming Jan 20th With Feedback Survey; v1 De-Auth Still On

    Did anybody really expect that someone at WotC was reading the text box responses from 39,000 playtest surveys? Edit: Debunked on Twitter by Ray Winninger as well as Alex Kammer. I trust Ray and Alex on this, so I believe WotC actually does read and compile the written feedback—my cynical hot...
  8. I

    WotC Talks OGL... Again! Draft Coming Jan 20th With Feedback Survey; v1 De-Auth Still On

    Two corrections: Kyle is 6 months on the job but took over responsibilities from Ray Winninger 3 months ago. And DnD Shorts says this is the doing of Chris Cao, not “Cox.”
  9. I

    WotC What is the last WotC adventure you played in or DM'd?

    Currently running Princes of the Apocalypse and the 5e conversion of Against the Giants. Playing in Waterdeep Dragon Heist.
  10. I

    D&D 5E (2024) New leak looks real bad

    Steampunkette has the right of it, but I think there's even more to it. (Edit to add: They don't need to revoke 1.0a in order to do what Steampunkette suggests, because they will control the terms for content on their own VTT regardless of what the OGL says.) I've been arguing since early last...
  11. I

    D&D 5E (2024) RPG Evolution: The Art of the Apology

    Yeah—I think Michael Tresca's analysis is mostly spot-on but should include a separate category for "Was It Honest?" A tale of two readings: I read the statement on Friday and thought "I do want more concessions, but these modifications make the updated OGL much less egregious than the draft...
  12. I

    D&D Beyond Cancellations Changed WotCs Plans

    I think this is all entirely correct but isn't really impacted by the OGL at all. Once Hasbro's VTT is running they can set whatever terms they like for what's allowed on it without bringing the OGL into it. If that weren't the case, they never would have promised (in their statement on Friday)...
  13. I

    Free League Develops Two New Open Game Licenses

    Interesting news—though it seems the Free League games I care most about won’t be included, unsurprisingly since they are based on licensed IPs (The One Ring and Alien).
  14. I

    Has Anyone Listened to the Opening Arguments Podcast on the Gizmodo coverage?

    OK. I assumed otherwise because you wrote that you hoped they would talk with someone who more fully understands the OGL and its history—whereas it seems clear to me from their Twitter that it was already far too late for that from the moment they first tweeted the upcoming episode's topic...
  15. I

    Has Anyone Listened to the Opening Arguments Podcast on the Gizmodo coverage?

    I urge you to read the “Tweets and Replies” section of the podcast’s own Twitter page from the past week. Both before and after the podcast aired. These guys knew exactly what they were doing. And good god, their arrogance and contempt for us might possibly exceed WotC’s. Even if you usually...
  16. I

    Has Anyone Listened to the Opening Arguments Podcast on the Gizmodo coverage?

    It’s nothing but cherry-picked information molded to fit their canned thesis: Journalist with grudge sparks moral panic over almost perfectly normal contract offer with just one unacceptable provision that nobody else is emphasizing! The one unacceptable provision is that WotC gets rights to all...
  17. I

    WotC might still want to stop Third Party VTTs in their new draft

    Oh for God’s sake, I think you’re right. They mean things like paid DMing on VTTs. They got me. That strange hyphenated word did strike me as odd, but like others, I thought they meant VTTs would be unaffected—which surprised me, since my whole theory of the case was that this whole thing was...
  18. I

    D&D 5E (2014) Sticking with D&D?

    I'm in four different 5e campaigns. Two as player, two as DM. All four will be sticking with 5e for the moment, though at least one group will move on to try out another system in a few months. (I'm championing DCC.) Our feeling is: some of us were playing D&D long before WotC was around. D&D...
  19. I

    WotC Walks Back Some OGL Changes, But Not All

    Exactly. I'll say this: my credence in the veracity of Gale Force Nine's and Weis & Hickman's allegations is up from about 80% to 99%.
  20. I

    The OGL -- Just What's Going On?

    There’s only one silver lining about that episode (which I just finished listening to): it is so patently biased in its cherry-picking of the relevant facts—the historical, the industry-related, and even the legal facts—that any listener already well informed about the OGL controversy will...
Top