Search results

  1. The Sigil

    D&D General So what about the SRDs?

    I am not a lawyer. This is not legal advice. I am using US terms here as that is where I am based; other legal systems likely have analogous but not identical terms (in the UK, I believe they use the term "Fair Dealing" where the U.S. uses "Fair Use"). The issue is that while you cannot...
  2. The Sigil

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    (Emphasis Mine) This. You did the match ahead of time to generate your "to-hit" chart; of course, once you started swapping among magical weapons with different +X values, you were probably "adding the plus to the roll" dynamically rather than "shifting X columns over on the to-hit table" in...
  3. The Sigil

    D&D General Read aloud text in modules: What are folks opinions about read aloud content?

    There are four cases into which I find boxed text falls when I'm running adventures: 1. "The Hook" - Especially for one-shots, this serves to ground the players in the world. It's also something I usually give the players to read in a handout in advance and I'll read a couple very short...
  4. The Sigil

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    True. It won't surprise many that know me that BG3 wasn't really my cup of tea (I don't usually care to run adult content in my games - probably because I'm still running games that often have teenagers whom I am not the parent of and I don't want to have conversations about that kind of stuff...
  5. The Sigil

    D&D General [rant]The conservatism of D&D fans is exhausting.

    I am not going to apologize for the fact that my tastes in D&D art run about the same as my taste in music... as in, "I prefer the stuff that was in vogue when I was in my teenage years" - because most of us psychologically are in the same boat... for most of our lives, our preferred "stuff"...
  6. The Sigil

    D&D General Matt Colville on the “Forever DM”

    There are kind of two different intertwined threads going on in this video: 1. Trying out RPGs that are not D&D. 2. Playgroups where the players expect the DM to do the prep work but they do not want to do any work other than show up. (This is the "Forever DM" or "my players would never run")...
  7. The Sigil

    Must You Tell Your Players What Adventure You Are Running?

    If my players are curious, when I run pre-published adventure, I am willing to tell them what it was I ran them through AFTER they are done with it.
  8. The Sigil

    Unbelievable Scale of AI’s Pirated-Books Problem

    Again, an LLM itself does not contain copyrighted material. It is basically a collection of facts ABOUT the copyrighted material (mostly 'what word probably follows this other word' but still is not the copyrighted material itself). Placing the LLM into the public domain would not give access to...
  9. The Sigil

    Unbelievable Scale of AI’s Pirated-Books Problem

    I am reminded of Weird Al's (rather tongue-in-cheek) reputed take on Napster - source: Items in your collection - World of Weird Al Yankovic when it was popular. He got "both sides" immediately. The problem, as with all things, is that when bad things happen to us, it's a tragedy, but when the...
  10. The Sigil

    Unbelievable Scale of AI’s Pirated-Books Problem

    In my defense, I did read the OP. I didn't initially read the article the OP linked to. ;) Hopefully my more recent posts show I have since read the actual article.
  11. The Sigil

    Unbelievable Scale of AI’s Pirated-Books Problem

    After reading the article linked in the OP, the below seems especially relevant" So yes, Meta's downloads definitely seem illegal to me (again IANAL, TINLA) and I would think that any LLM derived from it is not a "neutral" proposition but is also infringing ("fruit of the poisonous tree") but...
  12. The Sigil

    Unbelievable Scale of AI’s Pirated-Books Problem

    Ah, I didn't see that's where you were going with this. That makes it a fairer question. I did find an interesting article on the subject here: On Copyright, “Facts,” & Generative AI. I'll highlight a couple of excerpts here: I'm not familiar with the specifics of the Google Books case above...
  13. The Sigil

    Unbelievable Scale of AI’s Pirated-Books Problem

    C'mon Morrus, you know that's a "do you still beat your wife?" sort of question. Perhaps I should clarify when I made the statement above, every one of them was referencing physical books (I grew up before e-books existed - I know, I'm old!). I had a deep and abiding love affair with my local...
  14. The Sigil

    Unbelievable Scale of AI’s Pirated-Books Problem

    Misconception: LLM's store a copy of all data they were trained on, and therefore are prima facie breaking copyright if they do so without explicit permisssion. The Reality: LLM's do pattern analysis on the training data they are given. What winds up getting stored in the LLM database is a list...
  15. The Sigil

    D&D General Hands slot economy

    Interesting set of House rules. I think a lot of people have latched on to "Free Object Interactions" as "You Get One of These per turn" when the RAW say that you get one FOI during a Move or Action and to make second interaction, you have to use your Action. I note your rules allow you to...
  16. The Sigil

    D&D General Hands slot economy

    I rarely see this issue raised with dual wielders or two-handed weapon wielders, almost always, it's "sword and board" (usually making the argument that a shield stays strapped to your arm even if you open your hand to use it while spellcasting). I would simply apply a dose of common sense to...
  17. The Sigil

    What Published Modules Have You Run or Played Multiple Times?

    N4 - Treasure Hunt - I've run it as a 1e module, converted it to BECMI, converted it to 3rd edition, and converted it to 5th edition; each time, it was done for a group of new players (though in a couple of cases this was done in a "guest DM/teach a group to play" role where I did not continue...
  18. The Sigil

    Hasbro CEO Chris Cocks Is Talking About AI in D&D Again

    I stumbled across this and found it interesting as it feels like perhaps the "AI argument" is 100 years old. "Machinery is performing great service for mankind. But a Machine is not an artist. The high purpose of Machinery is to save Men and Women from ignoble and soulless labor, not to perform...
  19. The Sigil

    D&D 5E (2014) Can you hear the audible version of the Alarm spell if you are more than 60 feet away?

    Was going to point this out as well. I found this link - Rotary Hand Bell - Bell sounds 60db alarm up to 35 meters - [HS-RHB] - which suggests a fire bell sounds at 60 dB at a distance of 35m (114.8 feet - for ease of use, I will call that 120 feet). At 60 feet, then, that bell would be 66 dB...
  20. The Sigil

    Polygon: Indie TTRPG Companies are "sitting in their own little corners of the internet and wringing their hands"

    The problem with web 2.0 as I see it is that it is afflicted with a heavy dose of Dunning-Kruger. Almost never do I see someone say, “you know, I am not sufficiently educated on this topic to have an informed opinion.” Instead there is the attitude of, “well, I have a twitter (now X) account and...
Top